Baseball is a sport for romantics, and the idea of gritty determination taps a deep vein.
Still, if you look across MLB in 2023 you see that once the count reached two strikes, the resolution of that PA had an average OPS of .522. Five Twenty Two! That's worse than having a league full of Pedro Florimons*! And far below the .734 across all plate appearances in 2023.
Maybe Royce Lewis is so special that he wills himself to not fail with two strikes on a consistent basis for the rest of his career**, but it's hard to imagine a whole team being smarter than the experienced batters in the majors.
Joe Mauer was reputed to have pretty good command of the situation with two strikes. His career numbers show an OPS of .651, which is a lot better than the .522 in the majors last year. But then again, he put up outstanding overall numbers, with a career OPS of .827. No matter how good, or gritty, you are, you're gonna lose a couple hundred points of OPS by letting the count reach two strikes.
I find myself bringing this up every few months, but here's what I see as the real problem for the 2023 Twins with two strikes: they led the majors in the number of plate appearances that reached that number. Their overall performance is weighed down by a greater mix of the bad stuff than other teams. Bad outcomes are built strike by strike, not simply on the pitch that decides it. Over the long haul, once you reach two strikes you're pretty well hosed.
* To be fair, during his career Pedro Florimon himself OPS'ed .412 with two strikes, built on a BA of .133, LOL.
** Spoiler: so far in his career, Lewis hasn't, as he sports a 2-strike OPS of .576 .