There's no question about his defense, it's what he does at the plate, that needs stay at the same level as what he did the second half of last season. If he can do that, he's worthwhile. If he reverts to what he did in the first half last season, then he needs to ride some pine. I honestly thought he'd get traded this off season. I don't think his value had ever been higher. I do think he's finally a goner...either at the deadline, or after this season. No way they give him another contract.