You will search in vain for much defense of Grossman from these quarters. Although, Replacement Level doesn't mean, cut summarily from the roster. It just means, don't get too worked up, one way or another. If we didn't have Grossman, we'd have Palka. If we didn't have Palka, we'd have Brian O'Grady from the Reds, or any of several clones. Johnny Field probably comes to mind, too, on a different scale of fungibility - tweener CF glove, weak bat. Anybody a step up from these guys... that's what is scarce. Palka's not scarce, is my point.