Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • Twins News & Analysis

    White Sox 3, Twins 2: Walked-Off in Chi-Town


    Steven Trefz

    The Twins entered tonight's game with a chance to beat the White Sox while they were down. Instead, they gifted their division rivals another reason to hope again.

    Image courtesy of Kamil Krzaczynski-USA TODAY Sports

    Twins Video

     

    Box Score
    Starting Pitcher: Joe Ryan, 6.0 IP, 1 H, 0 R, 0 ER, 2 BB, 7 K (87 pitches, 60 strikes, 69%)
    Home Runs: Nick Gordon (1)
    Top 3 WPA: .Joe Ryan (.364), Nick Gordon (.177), Brock Stewart (.135)
    Bottom 3 WPA: Jorge Lopez (-.397), Caleb Thielbar (-.365), Jose Miranda (-.155)
    Win Probability Chart (via FanGraphs)

     

    Baseball Weather
    Guaranteed Rate Field felt like 45 degrees at the start of the game, and the baseball acted accordingly. Minnesota missed out on a chance to bust out the "Land of 10,000 Rakes" vest early, as Carlos Correa's 350 foot blast only traveled 336 feet...and the White Sox had a guy there.

    Joe Ryan Continues to Deal
    Ryan entered the game with a 5-0 record and a 0.82 WHIP with 40 strikeouts in only 34 innings pitched. In these chilly conditions, Ryan managed to continue his pinpoint control and ability to mix up his pitches effectively, to the tune of six strikeouts over the first four innings. It was the first time all season that Ryan navigated the first 12 outs of a game without giving up a run.

    Michael Kopech Picked a Bad Time to Start to Deal
    Kopech entered the game with 0-3 record and a 1.58 WHIP with 32 strikeouts in only 29 2/3 innings pitched, with a 6.07 ERA. Tonight saw Kopech hold the Twins hitless through five innings, mixing three walks with his six strikeouts. The Twins attempted to slow him down by taking time outs with 0-2 counts. That strategy rarely worked, and pointed out how smoothly Kopech was rolling, and how mystified the Twins batters were feeling.

    And He's Off! The Running Game Works...and Doesn't Work
    In the top of the third inning, Byron Buxton earned a walk with two out, and stole his first base of the season to put himself into scoring position. While he was ultimately stranded there, it was an encouraging development for a team needing to manufacture runs on the road. 

    The fourth inning, however, pointed out the downside of aggressive baserunning, as Trevor Larnach was thrown out attempting to steal on a Jose Miranda strike out. On a night where the ball wasn't traveling well, it was a calculated risk.

    Finally! A Hit! And Some Baserunners! And a Run!
    Buxton got the hit parade started with one out in the top of the sixth inning with a ground ball up the middle that just cleared under newly returned Tim Anderson's glove. Jorge Polanco came up next, and took a four-pitch walk to put runners at first and second for Correa. Kopech's next four pitches weren't even close to the zone, and now the Twins were in business with the bases loaded for Larnach, who just got under a Kopech fastball for a sacrifice fly to score Buxton to break up the shutout.

    It All Adds Up
    A key moment in the game occurred without a ball ever entering fair territory. With one out in the bottom of the sixth, Ryan was cruising along having only thrown 70 pitches. Anderson came to the plate, and 12 pitches later he had not only earned a walk, but had cost Ryan perhaps an extra inning of work later in the game. Andrew Benintendi eventually grounded into a 4-6-3 double play, but the damage to the beloved pitch count was done.

    Bullpen Time
    Gregory Santos was the first man up from the White Sox bullpen as he entered to start the seventh inning, and gave up a close call blast to Joey Gallo but escaped unscathed. Jorge Lopez entered the bottom of the seventh inning, and gave up a lead-off single to Andrew Vaughn and a go-ahead home run to Eloy Jimenez on only eight pitches. Eight. Pitches.

    Thank You Alex Colome! And Nick Gordon of Course!
    Luckily for Twins fans, the White Sox decided that their best chance at winning this game was to bring newly reinstated and Twins legend Colome into the eight inning. In a retrospectively masterful move, Gordon pinch hit for Michael A. Taylor, and suddenly the game was tied 2-2!

    Gordon Giveth, and He Taketh Away
    Twins Daily has been trying to figure out Gordon's role on the Twins as the season progresses, and other outfielders and bats come calling from the minors. Gordon showed in the bottom of the eighth how his impact to the roster carries into the field through his utility abilities as well by making an excellent catch in center field to end the inning. How he continues to play out this road trip will go a long way toward how long he stays on the roster.

    Let's Hand the Game to... Brock Stewart?
    Stewart got the call for the bottom of the ninth, and he walked Andrew Vaughn on six pitches, which led to the Billy Hamilton show entering the game as a pinch runner. Hamilton stole second, and stayed there after a successful White Sox challenge. Miranda made a nice play on a hard ground ball, but Hamilton took third on a groundout to third. The Twins then elected to intentionally walk Luis Robert, and pinch-hitter Adam Haseley flew out to Gordon in shallow center for the second out. Yasmani Grandal also walked, which brought up another pinch-hitter, Hanser Alberto. And yes, I'm stress-typing every one of these details out, please don't hate on me for it.

    Could Stewart escape the bases-loaded jam to bring us to extras? Yes! He! Can! Alberto flys out to Kepler, and we never had a doubt that it would all be ok...

    Extra Baseball!
    Jimmy Lambert came in to pitch the 10th for the White Sox, and he couldn't throw a strike to save his life. Luckily for him, Christian Vasquez and Gordon decided they would swing at anything within three feet of the zone for a strike out on a ball four, and a groundout on a ball three. That left "ghost" runner Gallo at third base with two outs, with Buxton up at the plate. Three pitches and a strikeout later (on a very high pitch), an opportunity was missed and it was up to Caleb Thielbar to strand his inherited runner as well.

    The White Sox began the 10th with some small-ball, with Elvis Andrus bunting Alberto over to third base. Anderson came up and laced a 2-2 pitch to a drawn-in Correa, who picked it clean and threw him out. Left-handed Andrew Benintendi was the next man up, and the Twins averted disaster as Thielbar bounced a fastball that Vasquez somehow miraculously kept around the home plate area to keep the winning run from coming in. All this relief quickly dissolved, however, when Benintendi laced a single to left field, ending the game at 3-2.

    What’s Next?
    The Twins will try to bounce back from this rough outing on Wednesday with RHP Louie Varland (0-0, 4.50 ERA) will be taking the mound for the Twins, while the White Sox will send out Twins-killer RHP Dylan Cease (2-1, 4.15 ERA). Tomorrow’s first pitch is scheduled for 6:10 pm CDT, and the temperatures should bring another low-scoring affair.

    Postgame Interviews

    Bullpen Usage Spreadsheet

      FRI SAT SUN MON TUE TOT  
    Thielbar 25 22 0 0 13 60  
    J López 20 16 0 0 15 51  
    Jax 16 15 0 0 9 40  
    Stewart 0 0 13 0 24 37  
    Pagan 0 0 23 0 0 23  
    Winder 0 0 23 0 0 23  
    Duran 0 15 7 0 0 22  
    Moran 0 0 0 0 0 0  
     
     
    South Dakotan Twins fan, on a quest to see a Twins series in every MLB stadium by 2025.
    Follow Steven Trefz on Twitter: @TwinsTrefz
     

    Follow Twins Daily For Minnesota Twins News & Analysis

    Recent Twins Articles

    Recent Twins Videos

    Twins Top Prospects

    Marek Houston

    Cedar Rapids Kernels - A+, SS
    The 22-year-old went 2-for-5 on Friday night, his fourth straight multi-hit game. Heading into the week, he was hitting .246/.328/.404 (.732). Four games later, he is hitting .303/.361/.447 (.808).

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    Featured Comments

    18 minutes ago, stringer bell said:

    It just isn't true that bunting a runner over is the proper strategy in extra innings with the "ghost runner". This isn't the 60s or 70s when contact was expected. Batters strike out and pop out at a high rate. Giving away an out to advance a runner is debatable at best, especially given that the other side will have a runner on second and no one out in the bottom half. The bunt over didn't win the game for the Sox, either. It was a hit with two outs by a left handed hitter against a left handed pitcher. 

    Correct. It's a very reasonable strategy when you're the home team and can play for 1 run to win, but tactically it's a more significant risk for the team in the top of the inning to play for one run, which is essentially what you're doing with by bunting the Manfred Man over to 3rd and surrendering the out.

    Chicago could bunt the guy over because there was no risk for them to lose and one run walks off the game. The road team doesn't have that advantage. 

    7 minutes ago, jmlease1 said:

    Because the 3-4-5 hitters were up in the 7th? I'm sure the thought process was to have Lopez (who has been excellent this season) face the heart of the order while trying to preserve the lead in the 7th, have Jax take the 8th, and Moran available to lock it down in the 9th for the save. With the score tied, I'm guessing they were looking at Stewart to run the 9th so that if they scored in the 10th they could again have Moran nail it down for the save. This is all fairly normal bullpen management.

    The real issue is how little the offense did last night; 3 hits is pretty miserable. They've got to do better even in cold weather...but dang it Correa only needed about another foot to put that ball out and then we're in a whole different story.

    Ryan did very well last night overall, although i was a little concerned about his inability to finish off a couple of hitters. He got the job done, but there were a few long ABs in there and that's really about the only thing holding him back right now from taking another leap.

    Unfortunately, López has had 3 subpar outings in a row after being essentially perfect.

    Don’t see what next level Ryan can be expected to leap to this season? He’s 5-0 with a sub 2.50ERA & in his only no decision he gave up one hit & no runs over 6 innings. Pretty top shelf to date!

    7 minutes ago, JD-TWINS said:

    Unfortunately, López has had 3 subpar outings in a row after being essentially perfect.

    Don’t see what next level Ryan can be expected to leap to this season? He’s 5-0 with a sub 2.50ERA & in his only no decision he gave up one hit & no runs over 6 innings. Pretty top shelf to date!

    He's doing great, but he still has stretches where he struggles to finish off a hitter (the Anderson AB last night was a perfect encapsulation of this) and he's been a little fortunate (which is why his FIP is sitting at 3.03 while his ERA is at 2.37). I'm still very happy with everything he's done this season, especially with how he's generally kept the walks and HRs down.

    If he can keep on this kind of a run, he's going to be fighting for an all-star slot, though!

    1 hour ago, stringer bell said:

    The White Sox have pretty good talent. I think they finish around .500 when all is said and done, unless they don't think they can contend and dump a lot of players. One area other teams have exploited against the White Sox that the Twins haven't is the bullpen. They have been a disaster except for playing the Twins. 

    Notable that Anderson and Eloy being back should also make them more formidable than the White Sox of last week…especially if their pitching wakes up from their terrible start.

     

     

    11 hours ago, Squirrel said:

    Don’t like losing to teams like this. I know it happens but … just shouldn’t happen. 

    It sounds like you are saying that you think our record against the White Sox this season should be 13-0. Is that really what you mean?

    2 hours ago, stringer bell said:

    It just isn't true that bunting a runner over is the proper strategy in extra innings with the "ghost runner". This isn't the 60s or 70s when contact was expected. Batters strike out and pop out at a high rate. Giving away an out to advance a runner is debatable at best, especially given that the other side will have a runner on second and no one out in the bottom half. The bunt over didn't win the game for the Sox, either. It was a hit with two outs by a left handed hitter against a left handed pitcher. 

    When you're the visiting team I think you have to play small ball and get that one run in because if you don't, the home team is gonna do exactly what the Chisox did and play small ball to get that run in.  The other thing it does with that one run is put some added pressure on the home team to get two so maybe they don't play small ball and do what the Twins just did to lose that game.

    The 10th inning rule requires at least some skill at bunting from all your guys, they just need to be able to put it in play.  Twins need to start putting at least a little emphasis on this and stop giving guys a pass.

    47 minutes ago, heresthething said:

    When you're the visiting team I think you have to play small ball and get that one run in because if you don't, the home team is gonna do exactly what the Chisox did and play small ball to get that run in.  The other thing it does with that one run is put some added pressure on the home team to get two so maybe they don't play small ball and do what the Twins just did to lose that game.

    The 10th inning rule requires at least some skill at bunting from all your guys, they just need to be able to put it in play.  Twins need to start putting at least a little emphasis on this and stop giving guys a pass.

    Here’s the thing heresthething—bunting didn’t get a run for the Sox in either the ninth or the tenth. Hitting with two outs produced the run in the tenth.  If I’m the home team in extra innings, I’d gladly accept the out for advancing the runner to third. If I’m the home team, I’d consider bunting, just because the infield and outfield in improves the hitter’a chances. 

    16 hours ago, tony&rodney said:

    Yup, can't win 'em all.

    Did anyone count how many swings and misses at high fastballs (more than four inches high out of the strike zone) there were in the game tonight. ? It seemed like an abnormal number of swings at pitches that cannot be hit.

    Varland up next.

    My thought exactly! I wish I would have counted how many swing and misses Twins had at pitches above the strike zone.

    I'm blaming the hitting coach for the Twins not having a plan when they go to bat. They must have known they were going to see a lot of high fast balls and had to lay off of them.

    5 hours ago, stringer bell said:

    It just isn't true that bunting a runner over is the proper strategy in extra innings with the "ghost runner". This isn't the 60s or 70s when contact was expected. Batters strike out and pop out at a high rate. Giving away an out to advance a runner is debatable at best, especially given that the other side will have a runner on second and no one out in the bottom half. The bunt over didn't win the game for the Sox, either. It was a hit with two outs by a left handed hitter against a left handed pitcher. 

    Flying out with 1 out and a runner on 3rd wins the game.  Your comment suggests it's not possible for hitters to adjust to the situation at hand and not swing for the fences when a fly ball or base hit wins the game.  This used to be called "situational hitting".  Lost art, I guess, but I just reject the idea that hitters cannot be expected to adjust their approach if the game calls for it.  

    6 hours ago, stringer bell said:

    The White Sox have pretty good talent. I think they finish around .500 when all is said and done, unless they don't think they can contend and dump a lot of players. One area other teams have exploited against the White Sox that the Twins haven't is the bullpen. They have been a disaster except for playing the Twins. 

    Set an over/under and we'll make a wager. They're 12 games under .500 right now. It'll take months of 90+ win baseball to get to .500 plus they'll need to maintain that by winning half of their games for another 2-3 months.  

    47 minutes ago, Woof Bronzer said:

    Flying out with 1 out and a runner on 3rd wins the game.  Your comment suggests it's not possible for hitters to adjust to the situation at hand and not swing for the fences when a fly ball or base hit wins the game.  This used to be called "situational hitting".  Lost art, I guess, but I just reject the idea that hitters cannot be expected to adjust their approach if the game calls for it.  

    Not if you’re the road team, which is what was being discussed. A road team playing for one when the home team is guaranteed a runner on second with none out is a losing proposition. It isn’t automatic that a hitter gets a 95 mph fastball down. Getting runners in from third with less than two out isn’t guaranteed. I don’t have the numbers, but I am pretty sure they’re available. The Whities had the winning run on third with one out in both the t ninth and tenth and couldn’t get either in with an out. 

    3 hours ago, stringer bell said:

    Here’s the thing heresthething—bunting didn’t get a run for the Sox in either the ninth or the tenth. Hitting with two outs produced the run in the tenth.  If I’m the home team in extra innings, I’d gladly accept the out for advancing the runner to third. If I’m the home team, I’d consider bunting, just because the infield and outfield in improves the hitter’a chances. 

    But it did get the guy to third and gives you more options to get him home.  The Twins played infield in, that could get a ball through that wouldn't if they were at normal depth.  

    Gotta be stats out there by now that show the progression in extra innings as to what teams are doing.  Would be interesting to see what is working.

    16 hours ago, stringer bell said:

    Not if you’re the road team, which is what was being discussed. A road team playing for one when the home team is guaranteed a runner on second with none out is a losing proposition. 

    My mistake as I thought you were talking about the home team.  I apologize.  Still, I don't know that I agree that playing for a run as the road team is a losing proposition.  This would suggest that the home team on average scores 2 runs in the bottom of the 10th.  Obviously this isn't true.  In extras teams play for a run, not 7.  If 9-1-2 is coming up in the top of 10, bunting still might be your best bet to get that run.  If it's 3-4-5, maybe you swing away.  




    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...