Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • Twins News & Analysis

    Twins Missed a Golden Opportunity with Byron Buxton Roster Move

    Byron Buxton's trip to the injured list created an opportunity for the Twins to make an impactful roster move. Instead, they doubled down on one of the most puzzling decisions of the season.

    Matthew Taylor
    Image courtesy of Bruce Kluckhohn-Imagn Images

    Twins Video

    Byron Buxton's exit from Tuesday night's game against the Kansas City Royals immediately became the biggest storyline surrounding the Twins. After leaving in the fifth inning because of discomfort during his second plate appearance, the club officially placed him on the injured list Wednesday with a hip impingement. That decision wasn't surprising. Buxton has been ailing since before the All-Star break, and he needed an injection Wednesday that would have sidelined him for at least a week, anyway.

    The corresponding roster move, however, was extremely surprising. Rather than using Buxton's absence as an opportunity to add an impact player or someone capable of filling the obvious void in center field, the Twins called up Tristan Gray. It was a move that continued one of the more confusing trends of Minnesota's season.

    Gray simply has not earned another opportunity at the major-league level, but he's getting one, anyway. He owns a .604 OPS this season, and if you remove his hot opening week, that number drops to .580. Defensively, he's struggled at shortstop, posting -4 Outs Above Average according to Baseball Savant. He currently owns both a negative fWAR and negative Win Probability Added. Nothing about Gray's performance this season suggests he deserves another call-up. Yet the Twins continue to show an unusual amount of faith in him.

    Earlier this year, Gray remained on the roster much longer than many expected. While he was with the club, he started far more games at shortstop than his production warranted. Now, with Buxton landing on the injured list, Gray was once again the organization's choice—this time, over some much more compelling alternatives.

    Buxton's injury leaves a massive hole in center field. Luke Keaschall is now the closest thing to an everyday option, but he has played just 11 games at the position and has not exactly looked comfortable there. That inexperience showed up again on Wednesday when he misplayed a carom off the wall, allowing Salvador Perez to take an extra base.

    Beyond Keaschall, the Twins technically have Alan Roden, Ryan Kreidler, and Kody Clemens who can handle center field, but their usage throughout the season suggests the coaching staff does not view any of them as legitimate options. Manager Derek Shelton said after the game Wednesday night that Kreidler could see more time in center, but that Keaschall would keep getting most of the run.

    That's exactly why this felt like the perfect opportunity to promote Walker Jenkins. Jenkins is widely regarded as one of baseball's top prospects and projects to be a cornerstone of the Twins' future. He's capable of playing center field and has looked every bit like himself since returning from injury. Since rejoining Triple-A St. Paul at the end of June, Jenkins has posted an .858 OPS, while continuing to show the all-around offensive skill set that made him one of the game's top prospects.

    There was a natural opening on the roster at a position that matched his defensive ability, for a team desperately looking for an offensive spark heading into one of the biggest stretches of its season. Everything seemed to be lining up for Jenkins.

    Some have pointed to the 40-man roster as the reason Minnesota chose not to make the move, but that explanation doesn't really hold up. The Twins have multiple players occupying 40-man roster spots who are not part of the immediate picture, and someone like Mike Paredes could have been transferred to the 60-day injured list to create space if necessary.

    If the organization truly believes Jenkins needs more development time, that is a separate conversation. But even then, Gray doesn't feel like the best alternative. Matt Wallner has been on a tear with St. Paul, posting a 1.089 OPS since the beginning of June. Gabriel Gonzalez has offensive upside while providing the right-handed hitting the Twins are losing with Buxton's injury. Kyler Fedko may not have impressed during his first taste of the majors, but he offers legitimate center field defense and speed off the bench—two things that became much more valuable the moment Buxton hit the injured list. Each of those players would have addressed a roster need more directly than Gray.

    Instead, the Twins once again chose a player whose overall production has been below replacement level. It's a particularly frustrating decision given where the Twins sit on the calendar. Every game matters as the trade deadline approaches. The front office is focused on buying, but how aggressively they do so could be calibrated by the way they play this week. Calling up Jenkins could have energized the clubhouse, excited a fan base looking for something to rally around, and filled an obvious positional need. Instead, the Twins made one of the least inspiring roster moves they could have made.


    What do you think? Should the Twins have promoted Walker Jenkins, or was Tristan Gray the right choice? Leave a comment below and start the conversation!

    Follow Twins Daily For Minnesota Twins News & Analysis

    Recent Twins Articles

    Recent Twins Videos


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    Featured Comments

    3 hours ago, laloesch said:

    Culpepper should have been called up by now arguably…

    I won’t argue with it. They have a shortstop performing well in AAA, which can’t be said about the big club. Are we figuring he won’t play as well there as the rotating cast of characters who have been filling in there since Lee moved to 3rd? I wonder how they could find out?

    50 minutes ago, Parfigliano said:

    Live game situations to learn to play CF.  What could go wrong?

    When Buxton went on the IL, someone needs to play centerfield. Roden, Martin, Larnach, Clemens, and Keaschall are the choices, unless the Twins use Gray at shortstop and Kreidler in center. Now, maybe the best option was to keep Outman but it sure seemed like people were done with him. Tough decisions get made when the club moved on from James Outman. There are consequences that are bound to occur with any of the guys on the roster playing out there unless it is Kreidler but we already know that 2-3 balls per game would slip through with Gray and more with Lee. Life is tough.

    3 hours ago, HarmonK03 said:

    Like they are having Luke do on the fly.  If his bat plays up here, you find room for him and I don't think Buck will be back anytime soon.

    Top prospect Max Clark -- No. 13 overall -- summoned by Tigers

    13 hours ago, HarmonK03 said:

    What new FO are you referring to.  Zoll has been here for almost 10 years and has been one of Falvey's key advisors for at least the last 5 years.  And there were no other personnel changes in the front office over the offseason other than Falvey leaving.  It is the same people pushing the same failed philosophies, the only difference Zoll is the final voice, not Falvey.

    The front office was Derek Falvey when Thad Levine was here and it was Derek Falvey after Levine left and Zoll took on the ceremonial position of Twins GM.

    Everybody knew that Falvey was calling the shots. Until Falvey left.

    That was liberation day and the restructuring, so Zoll has all the power, was brilliant. A GM should be able to have free rein to build out his vision. I’m very impressed with Zoll. The FO is hugely improved and the results show it.

    The front office is new because they totally restructured it to where, in my opinion, someone far more capable than Falvey has control of both roles, so that the GM is not having the Pres of BB Operations looking over his shoulder and able to pull rank at any time.

    You are either super cynical or haven’t been paying attention.

    What failed policies have turned a 70-92 team into a 55-55 team with virtually the same roster, except not near as much bullpen talent?

    The FO made a massive sweep of the organization, installing Derek Shelton, who has been terrific in myriad ways and Grady Sizemore plus Latroy Hawkins.

    I’ve see far more, not just competence, but inspired culture setting and far better field managing from Shelty than R.B. A massive difference.

    Basically, everything has changed and the moves that Zoll has made have been far better than Falvey in getting Yoendrys Gomez, Tommy Nance, Jack Anderson and now A.J. Minter, he of the 2.35 ERA and 1 WHIP for 2 out-of-the-top-30 prospects.

    The new culture and better than competence is what has allowed this team to be 55-55, even with a bullpen that is horrid on paper. Shelton has managed it superbly, getting the most out of it anyone could. 

    Even the switch to Tom Pohlad has been a good move.

    6 hours ago, Greglw3 said:

    The front office was Derek Falvey when Thad Levine was here and it was Derek Falvey after Levine left and Zoll took on the ceremonial position of Twins GM.

    Everybody knew that Falvey was calling the shots. Until Falvey left.

    That was liberation day and the restructuring, so Zoll has all the power, was brilliant. A GM should be able to have free rein to build out his vision. I’m very impressed with Zoll. The FO is hugely improved and the results show it.

    The front office is new because they totally restructured it to where, in my opinion, someone far more capable than Falvey has control of both roles, so that the GM is not having the Pres of BB Operations looking over his shoulder and able to pull rank at any time.

    You are either super cynical or haven’t been paying attention.

    What failed policies have turned a 70-92 team into a 55-55 team with virtually the same roster, except not near as much bullpen talent?

    The FO made a massive sweep of the organization, installing Derek Shelton, who has been terrific in myriad ways and Grady Sizemore plus Latroy Hawkins.

    I’ve see far more, not just competence, but inspired culture setting and far better field managing from Shelty than R.B. A massive difference.

    Basically, everything has changed and the moves that Zoll has made have been far better than Falvey in getting Yoendrys Gomez, Tommy Nance, Jack Anderson and now A.J. Minter, he of the 2.35 ERA and 1 WHIP for 2 out-of-the-top-30 prospects.

    The new culture and better than competence is what has allowed this team to be 55-55, even with a bullpen that is horrid on paper. Shelton has managed it superbly, getting the most out of it anyone could. 

    Even the switch to Tom Pohlad has been a good move.

    I have no idea what restructuring you are talking about.  The only change was Falvey left and Zoll became the top decision maker in February after the roster had been essentially set. But there have been no other changes announced.

    The PBO which was Falvey is the top position in the baseball operations and sets the vision from training, player development to setting the roster.  The GM should be the one leading the effort to carry out that vision.  You seem to imply that either Falvey was a figurehead or making all decisions by himself.  The same people advising and supporting Falvey are still there, just now they advise and support Zoll.

    Zoll worked for Falvey for almost 10 years and was his top advisor as GM for the last two plus years but sounded like he was a key advisor prior to Levine leaving as well.  Zoll obviously believes in this vision or he would have left.  This is still an analytics driven organization led by Zoll.

    And Falvey hired Shelton and the coaching staff, not Zoll so at least get the facts correct.

    This team is in the same spot as last year at this time, now hopefully they don't have a collapse like last year but let's wait until the end of year to say if it's been a success or not.  But I still do not believe this organization will be successful until they completely overhaul the front office.  That is the responsibility of Tom Pohlad, not to be making any personnel decisions.

    Twins just made a move for the pen getting A.J. Mintor from the Mets.  Decent LH RP.  Wonder what this means for Taylor Rogers or Kody Funderburk?  We traded 2 minor leaguers, the most notable being Billy Amik.  Mintor WILL help.  

    11 hours ago, tony&rodney said:

    When Buxton went on the IL, someone needs to play centerfield. Roden, Martin, Larnach, Clemens, and Keaschall are the choices, unless the Twins use Gray at shortstop and Kreidler in center.

    Too bad there’s no one in St. Paul with some experience in center and a little pop in his bat.

    8 hours ago, Greglw3 said:

    The front office was Derek Falvey when Thad Levine was here and it was Derek Falvey after Levine left and Zoll took on the ceremonial position of Twins GM.

    Everybody knew that Falvey was calling the shots. Until Falvey left.

    That was liberation day and the restructuring, so Zoll has all the power, was brilliant. A GM should be able to have free rein to build out his vision. I’m very impressed with Zoll. The FO is hugely improved and the results show it.

    The front office is new because they totally restructured it to where, in my opinion, someone far more capable than Falvey has control of both roles, so that the GM is not having the Pres of BB Operations looking over his shoulder and able to pull rank at any time.

    You are either super cynical or haven’t been paying attention.

    What failed policies have turned a 70-92 team into a 55-55 team with virtually the same roster, except not near as much bullpen talent?

    The FO made a massive sweep of the organization, installing Derek Shelton, who has been terrific in myriad ways and Grady Sizemore plus Latroy Hawkins.

    I’ve see far more, not just competence, but inspired culture setting and far better field managing from Shelty than R.B. A massive difference.

    Basically, everything has changed and the moves that Zoll has made have been far better than Falvey in getting Yoendrys Gomez, Tommy Nance, Jack Anderson and now A.J. Minter, he of the 2.35 ERA and 1 WHIP for 2 out-of-the-top-30 prospects.

    The new culture and better than competence is what has allowed this team to be 55-55, even with a bullpen that is horrid on paper. Shelton has managed it superbly, getting the most out of it anyone could. 

    Even the switch to Tom Pohlad has been a good move.

    One of the changes I have observed is that if a player isn't producing, he gets released or sent down. much more quickly under Shelton and Zoll.  Lewis, Wallner, Arcia, Raya, Fedko, Outman and a host of relievers. If a player can't field his position, he is moved to another position. Lee, Lewis, Keaschall, Bell and the next man steps up. 

    3 hours ago, HarmonK03 said:

    I have no idea what restructuring you are talking about.  The only change was Falvey left and Zoll became the top decision maker in February after the roster had been essentially set. But there have been no other changes announced.

    The PBO which was Falvey is the top position in the baseball operations and sets the vision from training, player development to setting the roster.  The GM should be the one leading the effort to carry out that vision.  You seem to imply that either Falvey was a figurehead or making all decisions by himself.  The same people advising and supporting Falvey are still there, just now they advise and support Zoll.

    Zoll worked for Falvey for almost 10 years and was his top advisor as GM for the last two plus years but sounded like he was a key advisor prior to Levine leaving as well.  Zoll obviously believes in this vision or he would have left.  This is still an analytics driven organization led by Zoll.

    And Falvey hired Shelton and the coaching staff, not Zoll so at least get the facts correct.

    This team is in the same spot as last year at this time, now hopefully they don't have a collapse like last year but let's wait until the end of year to say if it's been a success or not.  But I still do not believe this organization will be successful until they completely overhaul the front office.  That is the responsibility of Tom Pohlad, not to be making any personnel decisions.

    I'm implying that Falvey was the De Facto GM that presided over the losing franchise from 2020-2025 and that was probably why Thad Levine left.

    We see things differently. You think the front office is essentially the same and I feel that getting rid of Falvey and restructuring to one layer and putting a more talented person in charge has radically transformed it.

    We will need to agree to disagree, hope Zoll’s moves, callups, whatever lead to the playoffs and cheer for the Minnesota Twins today!

    5 hours ago, Cory Engelhardt said:

    Yup, I think moving Larnach to open a spot does make a lot of sense

    I noticed that too! And wondered if it meant what I thought it might mean. I’d like to see definitely Culpepper up at SS after trade deadline and Jenkins in the OF if they move Larnach

    5 minutes ago, Greglw3 said:

    I'm implying that Falvey was the De Facto GM that presided over the losing franchise from 2020-2025 and that was probably why Thad Levine left.

    We see things differently. You think the front office is essentially the same and I feel that getting rid of Falvey and restructuring to one layer and putting a more talented person in charge has radically transformed it.

    We will need to agree to disagree, hope Zoll’s moves, callups, whatever lead to the playoffs and cheer for the Minnesota Twins today!

    We can agree to disagree about Zoll abilities.  But you are wrong about Falvey.  He was hired in 2017 to be the President of Baseball Operations.  Levine was then hired to be the General Manager reporting to Falvey.  This is the typical set up in most front offices in baseball.  Levine actually left because it sounded like Zoll actually was becoming Falvey's more trusted advisor even though he was below Levine on the org chart.

    We truly don't know how Falvey and Levine worked and who did what.  But read the article from yesterday about Falvey's  comments about how he ran the trade deadline.  He was not acting as the de facto GM.

    It is purely opinion that Zoll is more talented when I have yet to hear of him receiving any calls from other teams for a promotion.  He was handed one here and did not necessarily earn it.

    5 minutes ago, Greglw3 said:

    I noticed that too! And wondered if it meant what I thought it might mean. I’d like to see definitely Culpepper up at SS after trade deadline and Jenkins in the OF if they move Larnach

    Culpepper looks a little rusty right now at the dish. I'm sure the Twins are monitoring his play.

    1 hour ago, tarheeltwinsfan said:

    One of the changes I have observed is that if a player isn't producing, he gets released or sent down. much more quickly under Shelton and Zoll.  Lewis, Wallner, Arcia, Raya, Fedko, Outman and a host of relievers. If a player can't field his position, he is moved to another position. Lee, Lewis, Keaschall, Bell and the next man steps up. 

    They sent Wallner down after 25 AB's in 24 so I am not sure this is the case.  Outman should not have even have been on the roster or Arcia for that matter.   So I am not sure that a lot has changed, it feels more like wishful thinking than actual results.

    1 minute ago, HarmonK03 said:

    We can agree to disagree about Zoll abilities.  But you are wrong about Falvey.  He was hired in 2017 to be the President of Baseball Operations.  Levine was then hired to be the General Manager reporting to Falvey.  This is the typical set up in most front offices in baseball.  Levine actually left because it sounded like Zoll actually was becoming Falvey's more trusted advisor even though he was below Levine on the org chart.

    We truly don't know how Falvey and Levine worked and who did what.  But read the article from yesterday about Falvey's  comments about how he ran the trade deadline.  He was not acting as the de facto GM.

    It is purely opinion that Zoll is more talented when I have yet to hear of him receiving any calls from other teams for a promotion.  He was handed one here and did not necessarily earn it.

    It's not worth arguing about. I believe that Zoll and Shelton are vastly superior to Falvey and Baldelli. You can say "You’re wrong, all you want" but I’ve watched how the franchise has been run since Falvey and Baldelli left and it’s light years better. 

    And I have a factual correction for you!

    The 2025 Twins were 51-59 after 110 games, not the same as this year and they had vastly more bullpen talent. Big difference between .500 with a very improvable bullpen, rotation and lineup vs lefties than 8 games below .500 with a peak bullpen.

    8 minutes ago, tony&rodney said:

    Culpepper looks a little rusty right now at the dish. I'm sure the Twins are monitoring his play.

    2 hits, was that yesterday? Looking at the silver lining. I think once he settles in, he’ll be, in total, a vast improvement over Kreidler, especially offensively with power and steals.

    Just now, Greglw3 said:

    2 hits, was that yesterday? Looking at the silver lining. I think once he settles in, he’ll be, in total, a vast improvement over Kreidler, especially offensively with power and steals.

    I'm watching the games and seeing how he looks and comparing that to his strong play before he was injured. Right now Culpepper is swinging at a few pitches he was spitting at earlier and he swung through a few middle middle gifts. He could tune in quickly .... we shall see. Kreidler is the better player at this time. Forget the stats and highlights and watch the games if you really want to see how Culpepper (or Jenkins) looks right now. 

    FWIW, Sabato continues to totally mash mistakes. I doubt MLB pitchers put the ball on the tee very often but Sabato is not missing when the pitchers go middle middle.

    7 minutes ago, Greglw3 said:

    It's not worth arguing about. I believe that Zoll and Shelton are vastly superior to Falvey and Baldelli. You can say "You’re wrong, all you want" but I’ve watched how the franchise has been run since Falvey and Baldelli left and it’s light years better. 

    And I have a factual correction for you!

    The 2025 Twins were 51-59 after 110 games, not the same as this year and they had vastly more bullpen talent. Big difference between .500 with a very improvable bullpen, rotation and lineup vs lefties than 8 games below .500 with a peak bullpen.

    Like bringing Gray back up, that is making this organization light years better.  My only point is, that the same people are making the recommendations in 2026 as in 2025 and before.  Zoll didn't necessarily pick out Gomez or Garcia to sign, someone on his staff that has been there before and after Falvey made the recommendation. Maybe Zoll is approving the better signing we will see.  But Shelton was Falvey's hire, so if you like Shelton, Falvey should get the credit for it.

    3 hours ago, HarmonK03 said:

    Like bringing Gray back up, that is making this organization light years better.  My only point is, that the same people are making the recommendations in 2026 as in 2025 and before.  Zoll didn't necessarily pick out Gomez or Garcia to sign, someone on his staff that has been there before and after Falvey made the recommendation. Maybe Zoll is approving the better signing we will see.  But Shelton was Falvey's hire, so if you like Shelton, Falvey should get the credit for it.

    HarmonK03, all I can say is RodC29! You say tomato, I say tomato. 

    And "Knock out a home run, shout a hip hurray...cheer for the Minnesota Twins tonight!"

    3 hours ago, Greglw3 said:

    It's not worth arguing about. I believe that Zoll and Shelton are vastly superior to Falvey and Baldelli. You can say "You’re wrong, all you want" but I’ve watched how the franchise has been run since Falvey and Baldelli left and it’s light years better. 

    And I have a factual correction for you!

    The 2025 Twins were 51-59 after 110 games, not the same as this year and they had vastly more bullpen talent. Big difference between .500 with a very improvable bullpen, rotation and lineup vs lefties than 8 games below .500 with a peak bullpen.

    This team is about ninety five percent built by Falvey.....




    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...