Miguel Sano’s Consistent Streakiness

Miguel Sano is the best option the Twins have for a slugging corner infielder until a better one comes along. Even after his horrible start and four more strikeouts in today's game, he has contributed 8 HR (team 3rd behind Cruz and Buxton), 19 walks (2nd between Donaldson and Arraez), 19 RBI (4th), an OBP of .303 (now 9th thanks to those 4 Ks) and 47 TBs (tied for 7th with Arraez).  His defensive performance at first is fine, and he is an acceptable substitution at third.

The difference this year is that Sano now has an understudy, one who partly due to youth has a greater potential up side than he does.  This means that Sano will have to solve that consistency issue and keep demonstrating that he's improving his game.  If not, then sooner or later it will be the the trading block. 

Sano himself still has potential upside.  He could have a revelation, or could make a resolution to be better that yields dividends.  At age 28, however,  time now works against him rather than for him.

Up or out.  In this game, and on this team, there's nowhere else for him to go.

Just ask yourself, what could you get in return if the Twins trade Sano?  The answer is not much at all.  And that is your answer on his supposed value.

How many more years will we have to debate this?

I will admit, in 2019, he had a great year.  But so did almost everybody on the team.  It was a fluky year.

When the last game is played in 2021, Sano's stats are going to show an overall poor season.  It was predictable.

5 minutes ago, TwinsChupacabra said:

Just ask yourself, what could you get in return if the Twins trade Sano?  The answer is not much at all.  And that is your answer on his supposed value...

 

 

Matters less what you get for him if there is a viable replacement ready to fill his role and perform at/above his level.  That day may now be on the horizon.

6 hours ago, TwinsChupacabra said:

Just ask yourself, what could you get in return if the Twins trade Sano?  The answer is not much at all.  And that is your answer on his supposed value.

How many more years will we have to debate this?

I will admit, in 2019, he had a great year.  But so did almost everybody on the team.  It was a fluky year.

When the last game is played in 2021, Sano's stats are going to show an overall poor season.  It was predictable.

 

 

I was critical of Sano when it was unpopular to be critical of him.  However, I think you are being overly negative.  His career wRC+ is 118 which is about 10 points above league average so that's not exactly poor.  He had a wRC+ of 125 in 2017 and 137 in 2015.  In 2016 he was leauge average.  His one truly "poor" year was 2018 when he struggled to a wRC+ of 83.  This year he had a poor April and a good month of May.  History does not suggest he will have a poor overall season.

As for his return, a guy who can really carry a team the way he can could have significant value at the deadline.  His contract terms are reasonable enough that a large market team would consider the 2022 salary and option in 23 ta plus.  For those who say his value does not matter, I disagree completely.  Cashing in on assets is how you continue to be good.  There are a number of teams that have demonstrated this the last decade.  This singular focus on the present is a good way to be bad perpetually.

I have also been a big critic of Sano.  The story shows his hot streaks, but what about his cold ones?  They are longer and horrible - including his poor playoff performances.

But also as others have also stated, the Twins do not have anyone else better at this time, so I'm fine that they keep putting him in the lineup for now.

He has always been a guy that gets on a hot streak and we all say he figured it out.  Then he gets in huge slump where he cannot even touch the ball.  I think at this point he is who he is.  He will have long stretches of terrible hitting and then good stretches of MVP level hitting.  

You cannot count on him carrying your team, but he can do it for some time.  You just need to accept you will want him to be benched for weeks at a time. 

The return from trading Sano may be better than we think.  We don't know how he is going to hit over the next 45+ days.  Should he have two week long streaks like the one last week, it could be mid-July and he is sitting around 20 home runs on the season.  A team in the hunt for a championship needing a DH/1B just might pay a lot more than we think to fill out a hole in their lineup.  And should Sano not work, maybe they trade Cruz to that team and move Sano into the DH spot most games with Kirilloff playing first. 

Sano has had a terrible March/April and a good May, but there's also some weird stuff in there to date. He's always been a player with pretty even splits, but this year he's gotten utterly destroyed by LHP, which has never been a problem before. Norm that out and his season looks a lot better.

Contact levels and BA are low all over MLB, so in context Sano still looks frustrating to Twins fans but clearly there's plenty more where he came from. He's going to be a streaky hitter: it's who he is. But you can survive that. The contract the Twins signed with Sano is actually a smart one, because once he gets deep into his 30's and that bat speed slows down, he's almost certainly going to have longer cold streaks and shorter hot ones. But for now, he should be able to adjust and be a low-average, good on-base, great power performer who can play a solid 1B and cover you at 3B if needed. That's pretty good value.

Yes, the K's can be maddening. But that's also part of the game right now. But he takes really good ABs, so it's not like he's flailing around. If they can find a way to keep him in a position to do damage on fastballs in the strike zone consistently...he's going to finish the year as an above-average 1B and an important power-producer in the Twins lineup.

Will Kirilloff be ready to replace him? Sure, but as we've seen this year, you need depth. Trading Sano doesn't get you a lot in terms of MLB-ready talent; you're gonna get guys who are in A-ball with upside that will need time to develop. It makes no sense to me to trade Sano unless you think the team is a total disaster and needs a total tear-down, and I'm not convinced of that.

I've made peace with Sano being a streaky hitter. I enjoy watching him play when he's on a hot streak and have learned to sweat it out when he's cold. That's been a part of the Twins experience since I've been following, I'd be disappointed to see him traded away, even if that may be the best thing for the team.

Mr. Sano,

I so very much enjoyed our reunion last night.

Love,

The Golden Sombrero

I have zero problems moving on from Sano..... make that less than zero. He is not compatible with a consistently performing lineup or sustained winning.

Good luck to him... elsewhere

Except for two pretty good weeks, Sano has taken the whole season off. In what line of work is that acceptable?