Biggest issue is that this team plays with no heart. EVERY decision is based on advanced analytics. A wise man once said that advanced analytics is an excellent means of predicting the past. Analytics has a measurement for everything. Except for things that can't be measured. Heart. What does a guy do when nobody else is doing anything. ‘Jump on my back. I’m driving the bus tonight.’ Infamous Kirby Puckett quote. Nobody on this team is driving the bus. Started when they moved on from Eddie Rosario. A guy who didn't have great measureables. But he did things nobody else did. He took a pitch 8 inches off the plate and drilled it for extra bases at a moment when nobody else was hitting. Can that be measured? Sure. And probably quantified as a negative. Should I bring up the fact that the guys (admins won't let me use the word(s) I want to use) playing his position this year have the worst OPS in the big leagues? Continued when they traded Nelson Cruz. Heart and soul of the team. Give them a pass on that one cuz they got Joe Ryan. Won't even mention multiple opportunities to bring Cruz back. Traded Berrios. OK, great. Got studs in return. (note sarcasm) Of course, a year later we found ourselves in need of a Berrios caliber pitcher and traded for Mahle. Of course when HE failed to bring the expected return we again found ourselves in need of more pitching and traded a guy who won some big American League batting award thingy for another pitcher.
NOW I'm about to cross into heretofore uncharted territory and ask one simple question: What has our lineup done to exhibit heart in the year since Miguel Sano's name stopped being written on the lineup card? Great hitter? Not really. Guy who makes everybody in the stadium and within earshot of a television stop and take notice when he's hitting? Absolutely. Guy who can wake up a line up and a crowd by hitting a ball to St. Paul. Yep.
Is the manager and / or coaching staff an issue.? Maybe. But at the end of the day the game is won or lost by the guys on the field. Do we have the right guys? Maybe. Do we have the right kind of guys. Maybe not.