1. Isn't it awesome that we have choices? And by choices, I mean generally good choices, not "who's still standing" choices.
2. I'm in the Maeda for Game 3 camp, but it's really, really close. I respect Maeda's past experience in the bullpen, but it was four years ago. I think the same thing that made him come up big in playoff relief will make him come up big as a Game 3 starter.
3. You can't play for the next round, but you can't ignore it either. Ryan is my Game 4 (ALDS Game 1) starter, so I don't want him on the Wild Card roster. So my only swap with you on the pitching side, Seth, is to have Ober in the pen rather than Ryan.
4. I'm with Paddack for the bullpen. All indicators are that he's been outstanding in his rehab. He hasn't pitched in a game for a long time, but it was "only" the beginning of last year. A factor in this is also that the Manfred Man rules go away in the playoffs, so I don't mind having both Ober and Paddack in the being able to go three or even four innings. And as RC's Birthday (which is the final day of the regular season, and if that's not a good omen, I don't know what is) notes, the "MLB Game experience" factor can be addressed with a couple innings against Oakland and a couple innings against Colorado.
5. The position player list depends on health, obviously, but I'm with you on including Buxton if he's remotely close. As you note in the comments, Seth, he's the most talented player on the roster. They are still showing Kirk Gibson highlight's for a reason. Even the threat of him pinch hitting has value.
6. The only other minor quibble is that I'd add a line down the middle of the page to divide the two columns.