DocBauer

Just to be clear, I have tremendous respect for Cleveland as an organization, and what they have done so far this year, even though I believe in my heart of hearts the Twins, overall, are the better club. Not sure I ever bought the "you can lose a division in April" until this season. Now, the year isn't over yet! But it's kinda crazy the Twins have bounced between the 1st and 2nd best record in MLB since that awful 7-13 start, or whatever the exact numbers were. I do think there is a regional NEGATIVE bias where we sometimes lament bad losses, giving games away, etc, when we examine our favorite team. Despite the payroll cutback, despite a rash of injuries, despite some bad losses that leave a bad taste in our mouth, the Twins are about 90% to reach the playoffs and still have a legitimate chance to win the ALC. Best record SINCE the bad start, or record overall, they are amongst the top 10 best win teams in MLB last time I looked. That's a reality, even if we want to lament woulda/coulda/shoulda scenarios. I absolutely believe in the LUCK issue we've been debating here. But "luck" is just a word to loosely describe what Cleveland has done thus far. If you want, how about we talk about regression to the "mean" instead? Barring a bizarre anomaly, if you flip a coin 100 times, you might get a run of either side, but in the end, you're going to end up pretty close to 50%. Statistics aren't just made up. While casinos and betting websites don't hit 100%...and yes, they try to manipulate betting lines to a degree...they use very advanced statistics in order to win over 50% of the time. And they always win in the long run. If ONE player ALWAYS performs consistently above or below BABIP in MLB, it's a trend for that player based on how they play the game, whatever it is they do. But when a TEAM has a BABIP...for example...over a period of time, it's either a BABIP that is going to naturally regress toward the norm at some point, OR, they will simply ride an anomaly that isn't supposed to happen for that length of time. Again, all due respect to Cleveland. And if you dislike the idea of "luck" one more time, just accept that there is a normal "mean" that real, logical statistics indicate "should be". BTW, "statistics" is not a 4 letter word. It's almost double in length first of all, LOL. But statistics have been all over baseball for decades! It's just grown and changed in measurement is all. Cleveland has been regressing lately. It's up to the Twins to continue trending upward. The season is coming around the 3rd bend and just entering the 4th, with the finish line in view dead ahead. The Guardians and Royals play 7 more games against one another, IIRC. And the Twins face Cleveland for 4 more games I believe. And there's a lot of other baseball in between. It's a shame our team started so damn slow and put themselves behind the 8 ball after 4 weeks. And it's a damn shame we BLEW about 3 or 4 games in the last 10 days that could have us tied, or in 1st place NOW. But it's also a damn shame if we can't recognize that we have a really good team as is right now. September should be really fun!

Martin had been pretty hot lately for sure. Is that due to maturation or to more consistent playing time? But there's still a lot if room for improvement before we get carried away and believe he's coming close to his potential. I'm not down on him at all. I think there's real potential inside. But defensively, while I've seen some improvement, he's average at best anywhere you place him. He needs to be better than that, especially in CF. Offensively, he's probably never going to generate much pop/power. I think 10HR, eventually, would max him out. But he's got enough pop in his bat, I believe, to be a solid doubles hitter who sprints out a few triples as well. He's got contact and OB ability, but for most of this season he's been below or well below average as a hitter. I get he's a rookie feeling his way still. But he's POTENTIALLY a pretty big cog in next year's team as a LF/CF option from the right side. As we sit here today, the Twins need a better version of Margot in 2025. Martin has the ability to be that better version. I sure don't see the Twins signing anyone to take that role. And right now, older and non rostered Helman is the only other option on hand. Assuming Keaschal makes a full recovery...and there's no reason to believe he won't...he's probably a better, duplicate version of Martin with more power, and MAYBE having the ability to play a little 3B in addition to 2B/1B/LF/CF. But he hasn't reached AAA yet, so I doubt he's ready until mid 2025? I WANT the Twins to sign or trade for a "better version than Margot" RH OF to be a 4th OF option. I just don't see anything other than a rebound, inexpensive FA option with crossed fingers type. So Martin has an opportunity to be really important next year. Here's hoping we get that version.

But I thought he was doing so much better and was so much happier away from the Nasty Man Rocco? LOL TOTAL tongue in cheek! UTMOST respect for Gray and his professionalism as well as his contributions for the Twins. Just couldn't bypass a small troll to a few haters. Forgive my humorous hijack. :)

Had to work so I only got the 9th inning and the post game, plus the box score, and the write up here. I'll be watching the condensed version of the game later tonight. Just a few random points: 1] Pablo....YES PLEASE. Keep it going. 2] Call me crazy, but I thought we'd get to Gray tonight. 3] Due to many circumstances, including injury delays, prospects don't develop in a linear fashion. I'm recalling a recent TD OP regarding Larnach usually hitting 2nd in the lineup. Tonight is an example of why. He's now at .257/ .328/ .457/ .785 for his quad slash line. We can debate lineup construction when everyone is healthy, but the guy has really developed this season. He might not be...yet anyway...what we had hoped for, but he's doing well. And I think there's another level yet to reach. 4] Isn't Wallner just FUN? He's also getting better. 5] Despite seeming to alternate between hot and cold at the plate...though right now Jeffers is heating up again...offensively and defensively, do the Twins have the best catching duo in MLB? 6] No more injuries, the Twins need to nurse/work with/keep trusting Festa and Matthews in the rotation. While he might or might not turn in to an immediate pen stud, Varland moving to the pen soon gives them another power arm that's usually been proven to be very good for a couple of innings. Could a healthy Funderburk make a late season surge to displace Okert? Did what we saw of Winder in his last promotion mean he's ready to contribute on a regular basis? Any chance Paddack comes back like he did late in 2023 to add another good arm to the pen? If the rookies can just be solid and not hit a wall, might we end up with a good pen to end the season? 7] Lee is on rehab and might be back soon. Maybe I'm reading between the lines too much as an optimist, but it sounds like Buxton's hip is feeling better and he might be ready in a week? Correa has moved to sprinting, which is one of the final tests, as I understand his rehab. He's not quite right yet. But he is better. He's probably further away than Buxton. But at some point, Correa will be back, even at 80-90%...but we can cross fingers for more. Is it possible the Twins are 100% come mid September? 8] The Twins are the best team in a much improved and surprisingly competitive ALC, still suffering from their horrendous start to the season. No more injuries or rookies hitting a wall, I think the ALC can still be taken. I'm excited!

@Dman, agree on learnjng to pull the ball more. He hasnt been proper "challenged" to a certain degree since he hasn't had to repeat performances against teams and pitchers much yet. Again, he seems to be built pretty solidly, and appears to be pretty athletic. He reminds me a little bit of Martin, despite being shorter, primarily an INF, and LH. But like Martin it's not so much needing big HR power to be viable, it's keeping a good eye, good contact profile, but being able to pop the ball down the line and in the gaps. Thats the kind of power needed with his skillset, IMO.

Did they dodge a bullet by not signing Maeda? Yes. Did they dodge a bullet by not signing Gray? Yes and no. With Ryan out, I'd rather have Gray in the rotation. But he's slipped a bit expertly and isn't getting younger. And he's still owed some good $ the next 2 years. While we certainly miss Ryan at the moment, having SWR in the rotation has been great, and will pay future benefits at a low cost. Further, Festa and Matthews are getting great experience at the moment. So I'm going to answer yes and no. The problem is a general inaccuracy in regard to the "savings" being re-invested on the team in any way. Completely false narrative unless we begin to see changes in 2025 and beyond. Just ONE proven, trustworthy pen arm and a better RH 4th OF with any "savings" could have really helped. Maybe another 3 to 5 wins at this point? So yes...and no...and a PLEASE.

Which is why I mentioned I THOUGHT there was an opportunity to just keep Varland when Ryan went on the IL. Again, I could be wrong.

Not trying to distract from the OP as I think there might be some NFL and NBA references to be made, but the Rangers from DC is different from the Twins move. Where do the Senators go bankrupt, not play, and then are bought and moved to MN? And even if they DID go bankrupt, even for a season, isn't that the franchise bought by Griffith?

Read everything. Liked a couple of posts. Doesn't really matter because as a fan, I'm actually pretty emotional about Kepler. (Not that I haven't been about many past Twins) Since the day he was signed he grabbed my attention. Maybe it was my German background. Maybe it was a kid from Europe instead of Latin America. Maybe it was his parents story. I just fell in love with a kid/prospect that I had hopes for. Coming up through the system, I truly felt we were going to see multiple All Star appearances. He could run a bit, play defense, and had one of the sweetest LH swings I've ever seen. Over the years I've argued, "look at his background" compared to American HS kids. I've often stated "just wait and see when he really catches up". In 2019 I really thought we were finally seeing what Max could become. Just being honest, even as a fan, I was ready to move on in 2023 when he continued a downward spiral. When the 2nd half of 2023 happened, and he "opened" the possibility of K-ing more but hitting the "damn ball hard" I felt I FINALLY saw the Kepler bat I'd been waiting for for years. Now, he was always solid and generally productive, but never what I envisioned or believed. I actually thought he'd carry that over to 2024, on his Twins farewell journey, toward another ACL flag and playoff appearance. Alas, it really hasn't been a journey I thought I'd see. I will always remember how great he was in RF, and that's going to be hard to replace. And I'm going to remember more than a few walk off moments, including this season, that Kepler gave us. He's a quality young man, has been a quality Twin for years, and I'm hoping for a few more quality moments before 2024 is over. The PRACTICAL side of me sees not only finances and talent coming up, but talent already here. While Kepler is a quality defender, offensively, Larnach and Wallner have better OB% and SLG% as younger, cheaper players. Wallner moves well once he gets a couple steps under him...Larnach similar...and has a tremendous arm. Spending so much time in LF, it might take a while for either/both to understand RF in Target. I think we'll be OK overall, though we're going to lose some range vs arm ability. I'm just being practical, not emotional. Wallner in RF will be the more productive player overall. Based on ability, potential, and only slightly SSS that seems certain. None of this means I'm not still a fan of Kepler and his service to the Twins over many years. But like Polanco, there is a time for a team and player to move on. And I will wish Kepler the best of luck going forward as a fan, except when he faces the Twins. *cue the traditional RPR dislike and comment I will ignore.

Got a lot to say here. SURPRISE! LOL. 1] Varland still has a CHANCE to be a good ML SP. He's OK-ish right now. Solid for 4-5 innings with a chance to be better. His offspeed stuff is probably the biggest issue. Bit it's OK to be a really good RP as well. Like Jax, why can't he work on honing his other offerings to make him a great RP instead of a mediocre SP? 2] I'm OK if the Twins move him to the pen ASAP. I think it's where he belongs, and he can thrive there, and only get better. Again, Jax as an example. But it's OK if they keep him as a SP option for a couple more weeks until we see if someone hits a wall. For all the talent and future possibilities of the kids in the rotation, it's a very real possibility SWR, Festa, or Matthews just hit a wall or get figured out. It's OK to give Varland a couple more weeks, and see what happens, and have him in reserve for those couple of weeks. 3] I KNOW this won't be popular, but if the Twins needed ANOTHER SP option, and Varland were in the pen tomorrow, I'd honestly rather give Dobnak a shot before anyone else. He's having a good season, and past performance and by his own admission, he's never been comfortable coming out of the pen. I hope ANOTHER starter isn't needed, but I'd rather see him than anyone else at AAA for the next month, if needed, again, Varland in the rotation. 4] I might be incorrect in how the timing worked, so forgive me. But wasn't there an opportunity when Ryan went to the IL that the Twins couldn't have kept Varland up along with Festa and Matthews? I swear there was a window with injury and double header where he could have stayed. If I'm correct, he could have stayed as a pen option who could piggyback anyone if they ran in to trouble, or, to throw 2-3 innings and lengthen the pen, thus keeping himself stretched out. Again, forgive me if I'm wrong, but am pretty sure that window was open. I'd keep Varland at AAA, for now, as @chpettit19 stated, until mid September if possible. I think he then moves to the pen, and he should be there going forward. Again, why can't he get even better ala Jax? I don't care if he's wild, he's got better stuff and a better future, I'd find a "tired arm" with Okert and bring Funderburk back when healthy. While wild, he has better stuff and can actually get RH batters out. IDK if what we saw of Winder is real or not, but I'd like to see if he can follow the "Sands" model and actually help. For the NOW, I'd like to see what Henriquez can do. His final line against the Padres Wednesday was skewed by a horrible play from Margot. Here's hoping Paddack can come back and provide another high velocity arm like he did last year. But for Varland, I'm HOPING he can remain stretched out "just in case" for another couple of weeks and then make a permanent transition to the pen.

Payton Eeles has been getting quite a bit of ink over the past few months since his signing out of Independent Ball. And rightfully so as he's been an interesting surprise. And I thought a separate thread might be due, even though the season at AAA isn't done yet. He attended Coastal Carolina for college. While not a Blue Blood program, the school has built up a pretty respectable athletic department over the past several years. The baseball program won the CWS in 2016. I believe that was their first appearance there? For his career, Eeles produced a quad slash line of .381/ .445/ .489/ .934. He never had a great deal of power, but he did flash some speed in SB success. As one might expect from a college player, he moved around the dirt some, but he was primary at 2B...127 games...and SS...72 games. While he didn't produce power, and didn't have a 1.000+ OPS, his quad slash line was pretty impressive. So why wasn't he drafted? I can't speak about his defense, but he was trusted enough to see a fair amount of action at SS, so he must not have been a butcher. But when you don't have a lot of power, only stand 5' 5", and the draft is only 20 rounds, you tend be an afterthought when the draft comes along. There's been a lot of fair discussion as to how he ranks as a prospect in the Twins system when the dust settles and the smoke clears on the 2024 MILB season. After all, what he's doing hasn't been seen...at least in these parts...since Randy Dobnak skyrocketed straight to MLB as a pitcher from the Independent Leagues. Now, I'm not comparing the two...for goodness sake one is a pitcher and the other is an INF...I'm just saying his journey so far is rather unprecedented. So far, in 2024, at THREE different stops, he has a cumulative quad slash line of: .315/ .431/ .482/ .913. He's produced 27 XBH so far, including 7HR, which is only 3 short of his college career. That's not to say he's suddenly tapped in to power, but it's interesting to see what he's done in 270 AB between those three levels. He's also flashed some SB ability going 30-9 in attempts. Ironically, his worst numbers so far...while still good...came in his brief stay at A+. Despite where he came from, or the journey he's on, the question is: "Is he an actual prospect"? Well, his numbers are very impressive in regard to AVG/OB/and OPS, despite not being a real slugger. And he's only 24yo until November, and is producing well at AAA ball. IMO, despite such great success so far, and not old by any means, he's still "new" to pro ball. (No offense to the Independent Leagues). He doesn't have a track record of facing teams, and pitchers, at any level multiple times. There's got to be a reality check that holes in his swing/approach haven't really been diagnosed yet, yes? Further, despite some decent XBH numbers so far, and carrying a reported 180lbs on his 5' 5" frame, questions about actual pop/power must be asked. The days of simply being a "punch and judy" hitter are gone in MLB. What I find of great interest is the Twins decided to not only promote him very quickly, but they also chose to skip him past AA entirely after a rather brief time at Cedar Rapids. That tells me he's of interest, as well as being too advanced for anything AA or below. I see him as a good contact, high OB, scrappy hitter who can spray the ball with a few liners and rappers to keep the opposition honest. He should be able to steal a few bases. If he can play a solid 2B/LF and "emergency" SS he's got a chance. Goodness knows he's going to have a small strike zone to frustrate pitchers, LOL. But before we get too excited about a great story, let's remember he needs to show he can CONTINUE to perform with the bat when he stays at a level more than a month, and sees teams/pitchers more than once. Further, can he spray the ball and continue to show some XB ability? If not, ML pitchers and defenses will eat him up. Aldo, less we forget, some guys like Lee might be ahead of him at 2B, as well as Julien...who might end up playing some 1B...and Keaschall is right behind as an additional 2B option...though he might end up as a dangerous, utility player. I don't say any of that to be a downer on a kid that is a tremendous surprise! If he were drafted in 2022 and performing the way he is, and already at AAA, with ALMOST 2 years under his belt, he might already be a top 20 prospect. I'm only trying to take a realistic approach to a very different player, in a very different situation, who is performing particularly well, but is in a unique situation. What are your thoughts and opinions on Eeles going forward?

Pretty much agree with the rankings as Seth has them. And I agree with placing Varland on that list as he's almost certainly going to be in the pen at some point. The question is when? I'd love to see it done now, but if anyone else falters or gets hurt in the rotation, you're turning to Dobnak as next man up probably. So I don't see Varland in the pen until the last wee or two of the season. But I do see it. While it's easy to blame ownership for the current situation, I can't bring myself to blame the FO for depth issues. Topa might have been a realnhelp, but out for the entirety of the season thus far. Duarte showed real promise...out for the season early. Moran...out for the season. Winder...slowed foe about half the year. Weiss...never got started until just recent who knows if he MIGHT have surprised. Stewart has barely thrown all season and is out until next ST. Staumont was a cheap flier that offered upside but didn't pan out despite some solid early results. Just a couple less injuries and the pen is in better shape. Even better if we could move Varland to the pen now and have Funderburk back instead of Okert. I was OK with Okert for most of the season ad a 2nd LH, but he's been pretty bad as of late. Funderburk hasn't exactly arrived yet, but he's got some great stuff. SSS for Henriquez and Winder, but I'm interested in them as my 7th and 8th arms. When Varland does make the move, we might be 5 deep. IF Paddack makes it back this season, he'll be in the pen. We're even deeper then. If Funderburk does makenit back, I'm wondering if they'd trust the stuff vs the not performing vet? I don't hate the potential post season pen. I am worried about how we finish the regular season with the current pen, however. I'd get Winder back up ASAP to see if his earlier glimpse is for real. And I'd like a good, fair look/opportunity for Henriquez as well. His numbers against the Padres in the 3rd game were skewed by a blown Margot play.

All due respect to the man and career that is Carlos Santana, he's defied father time for TWO rebound seasons now, and even if he's willing and wanting to come back for the same $5M ish deal in 2025, would the Twins be smart to bring him back at 39yo with fingers crossed he can beat the aging process for a THIRD season? I mean, anything is possible, but it's pretty doubtful. And I don't believe the Twins will take that gamble. That being said, you can almost ink in 11 guys for 13 spots next season, with Martin written in the erasable ink version. (Is that even still a thing?) 1B is the biggest, solo hole with Miranda able to play there, but who else right now? I have a lot of faith still that Julien's talent is going to win out and we're still going to see a really good producer there. But I don't want to go on to 2025 guaranteeing him a spot at this time. And while I'm begining to think Severino MIGHT turn out to be a solid ML 1B, the jury is certainly out still. I'm not saying Kirilloff is any kind of solution for 2025. But he's going to have an option left. And if they were willing to spend about a $M and a half for a questionable pen arm, they'd spend $1.5-2M for a soon to be 27yo LH OF/1B, who has produced when healthy, on the hope that 2025 might be the magical season where he finally IS healthy. Now, I think it's 50/50 he's traded to another club who thinks along the same lines, and moves their RH OF or pen arm they're disappointed in for a mutual "disappointment/bounceback" kind of deal. But 1B IS a question mark right now and it's not going to be dealt with via a big $ deal for anyone, so more options are better. A healthy AK can be part of the 1B equation, or the last man on the bench who can play 3 spots...if only average at best...and DH/PH. He can also be removed at any time without crippling the team financially in any way. It just makes sense for a $2M gamble for one more year...unless he's part of the previously mentioned "make good" trade scenario.

Letting Hoffman go after flashing in ST when the other arms kept had options was a huge mistake. A mistake that made no sense then, and even less now. Blewitt is having a solid year for the Saints, and he may have room to get better, but he's not exactly dominating with more hits than IP. I'm more interest3d in seeing Henriquez sustaining good performance for a time. Possibly even Winder...when he's eligible to come up again...if his latest stretch is believeable. Nothing against Blewitt, but being good, not great, at AAA doesn't make him another Hoffman simply because they have a similar pitch mix, IMO.

SWR was pretty good except for 1 pitch. A little disappointed the offense didn't add an additional run or two. I think I would have brought Alcala in instead of Sands who doesn't seem to do nearly as well with runners already on base. Santana has produced WAY above my thoughts and predictions and I've been pretty honest in that. My biggest concern for Saturday isn't who's starting, but Jax and Duran not available. But then again, Texas has gone to their pen a bunch as well. Next 2 games might be slugfests

His age is actually about right for AAA overall. He's a late bloomer with a solid set of skills who's never gotten his shot yet. Were he a RH hitter, he probably would have been up already. His biggest issue is being a LH hitter. At some point, you can have too many LH bats. Now, recently, that hasn't been an issue due to injuries and the such, to be fair. I don't know about his arm. I've read and heard reports that he's a legitimately good defensive CF. Margot is average at best these days. Martin is below that. He's made some good plays, but probably as many poor plays out there. Right or wrong, there IS a concern with the Twins...and a 13 man roster...of having enough RH bats to face LHP about 25-30% of the time. Whether anyone wants to admit it or not, Margot HAS produced WHEN facing LHP at a slightly better than league average. I doubt anyone has another GG caliber CF just sitting on the bench to replace someone like Buxton when he's out. You fill in best you can. Martin, unfortunately, hasn't produced much with the bat, more has he been particularly good defensively. And he's actually been worse against LHP, surprisingly. Castro is needed at SS right now due to a pair of injuries, so he can't really help in the OF. Keirsey might play very good defense in CF. But can he hit at the ML level? We don't know yet. Personally, the way the roster is right now, I think having both Margot and Martin handcuffs them and I also would have given Keirsey a shot. Especially since Martin simply hasn't taken a step forward in any area. Right now, the OF has 3 LH batters and a single RH one in Margot. But with Farmer back to help the INF, and Martin producing next to nothing, again, I'd just say "the hell with it, get Keirsey up here to play defense and hit 9th and let's see what happens". FWIW #1: The even older Helman is having another excellent AAA season, but keeps getting injured. FWIW #2: I'm not going to disparage the young Martin who might, and hopefully will, take a step forward next year...BUT...this only goes to show the absolute need for ONE, solid, well rounded, but affordable and not great RH OF needed for 2025. Think Margot, but better in CF, and not a disaster against RH pitching. Through trade or FA, that SHOULD be a priority for the FO. Think someone who can have a .680 OPS against RHP, but .720 against LHP with a little pop and the ability to play across the OF. Not a stud, not an All Star, just a good, solid OF who doesn't have to play daily, but who can if you need him to without embarrassing himself or be a black hole in the lineup.

I'm going to disagree. And I like the kid! I was hoping they'd hold back, put him on the roster, and then put him on the IL so he might get some practice reps come December. I guess they don't feel he'll be ready enough to do that. And I'm pretty sure his IL designation now mean NO field time, even if he's a quick recovery. I think he's in a perfect situation in regard to coaching, system, and talent. And I know some guys come in and perform very well their rookie season. But I've just seen too many 1st round kids come in and get eaten up by the speed and talent of the game. And with all due respect to McCarthy and his skills, he wasn't in a system in college that was centered on the QB and the passing game. I think he can continue to learn a lot from the side, and get ready for 2025. It's not just learning the offense, it's learning the speed of the game and what NFL defenses bring. Missing actual practice time STINKS! But I believe he can continue to learn and get ready for next year.

First of all, I don't believe Vazquez is going anywhere. In the grand scheme of things, his $10M isn't back breaking even for a team pinching pennies. There's also not an obvious replacement for him as a CATCHER, and what that implies, and they'd probably have to eat part of his deal in order to move him. They'd end up, probably, with negative value overall. Vazquez is an excellent catcher, Jeffers a solid one. Jeffers is the better bat, Vazquez is what he is, an OK enough bat...generally...to balance his defensive value. Let's look at what this duo has done to date, with about 40 games left. Jeffers has a .761 OPS despite highs and lows. That's not only above league average, it's WAY above average for the catcher position. Despite horrible lows and some recent highs, Vazquez has a .620 OPS. COMBINED, they have accounted for 22HR and 78 RBI. Yes, some of Jeffers production comes from some DH appearances. But not enough to completely mess with the overall numbers. If both simply keep producing at their current pace, with 40 games to go, they would project to 29HR and 103 RBI. That's AMAZING, even when you swipe away a couple HR and RBI from Jeffers spending some time at DH earlier in the first half. What the Twins are getting, even with some hot and cold streaks from both catchers, is solid defense and game calling overall, and production from the catcher spot that few teams can probably come close to. This works!

"Don't click, don't click, don't click....DANG...I clicked!" Lopez, Ryan, Ober, SWR, Paddack all locked in right now. Varland might just move to the pen full time and begin as a 2 inning option with the potential of being special. That STILL leaves Festa and Matthews as the 6th and 7th arms ready to go. Right behind them will be Morris, Lewis, and Culpepper not far behind. Maybe Nowlin as well? (He might jump to the pen and make it quickly as a result). Where does Disco fit? IF Paddack is moved to clear his rather small $7M deal, that $ could be better used for a better version of Margot...instead of just trusting enough improvement from Martin...and/or a solid BP from either side. Vazquez isn't going anywhere, and he shouldn't. This is just such an obvious NO it's hard to believe an OP was even written about the possibility. But sure, as others have said, if he wants a MILB deal to rehab and prove his worth with a split deal that offers him $4M if he makes it back, why not. But that's it.

Agreed on Margot being used more than expected. But you have to expect and anticipate things like that happening, right? So that RH bat you have as a reserve should be acceptable against RH arms and Margot just isn't. Also agree with Castro as being one if those RH options. And he'll continue to play OF as well. Total agreement there. But I see him as a super utility player, the 10th man so to speak, and not just an OF. Right now, that job next year probably has Martin's name on it. But how much will he improve both with the bat and the glove between now and then is the question. I'd really like to see another option brought in. Not sure at this moment who that might be.

As a RH hitter who has been solid against LHP? He's been just fine. Even very good at times. He's actually made some quality plays in the OF, but also made some very poor ones. So defense is a wash. Getting him for only $4M, and a solid prospect back in return, has been just fine for 2024. Not great. Not exciting, but just fine. I'd really like to see the Twins shoot higher for 2025 though. I'm not sold on Martin to be that guy. I have hopes. I mean, he's still only a rookie feeling his way. He could turn a real corner for 2025 and be THAT GUY. He has the range for CF...LF of course...but for every quality play he's made in the OF, he's probably made 2 bad reads/routes that have lead to big hits for the opposition. Ditto at 2B, though he's looked better there lately, IMO. He's not really hitting, has displayed little to no power, and has an OPS about 50 points below league average. What's most concerning is that for THIS SEASON at least, he's actually performed worse against LHP. Margot has been solid. He's actually been a benefit against LHP no matter how frustrated some fans been with him. But he won't be back in 2025. But somehow, FA or trade, the Twins really need to come up with a RH OF who can beat up LHP, and not be embarrassed against RHP. Just betting on Martin making major improvement does nothing for next season's roster/lineup.

PART 2: While there is something to be said about the OPS at certain positions, 1B being among them, I think we need to start changing out perceptions of a player being "wasted" at a position die to their talent. I mean, if I have a PAIR of All Star 1B but I need to play one of them at DH to get both in the lineup, am I really "wasting" one of them? As previously stated, I'm not of the opinion Lewis needs to, or is going to, move off 3B any time soon. But let's just say it turns out Lee is a superior 3B defensively and the fine offensive player most believe he will turn out to be. Meanwhile, Correa is at SS, and 2B is manned by a rejuvenated Julien, or perhaps Keaschall back 100% at some point in 2025 and ready to go, or looking even further ahead, Culpepper destroys milb staffs and is ready in no time. What would be wrong with Lewis at 1B? A few years back, the Angels had a 2x All Star, 3x GG winner, and a 1x SS award winner in Darin Erstad splitting time at CF and 1B. 2x All Star, 1x MVP, 1x GG winner and 2x SS winner, and NL ROY winner Cody Bellinger also split time between Caf and 1B. Why? Because they could! I want the best starting 9...counting DH options...and a solid bench. I don't care who plays where if they can play "where" successfully. IF the very best lineup the Twins could put on the field come 2025/2026 and beyond meant moving Lewis to 1B, or Correa at some point, or Keaschall, or Culpepper, etc, I don't care. I just think we need to recognize that MLB is becoming more and more about the best players on the field and in the lineup on a daily basis. The idea ISN'T about IGNORING defense. You don't WANT a butcher in the field anywhere. But you do want the best overall athletes and productive players on the field and in your lineup daily.

PART 1: Well, this article sure got the fingers going didn't it? But I really disagree with the premise. Especially the part where it was stated: "feeling confident about Lewis at any one position is nearly impossible". Huh? The early part of the OP remarks about what a great athlete he is, and applauds his hand eye coordination, but we can't feel comfortable playing him anywhere? Excuse me??? Let's retrace a bit shall we? Royce played 3B in HS as there was a quality SS upper classmate ahead of him. He moved to SS as a senior. He was a top 100 prospect as a SS, though there was some concern if he'd stick there full time. I don't recall anyone ever stating he'd be a BAD SS, just maybe not good enough to be a full time starter, but the jury was certainly out. Fast forward past TWO knee injuries and he moved to 3B basically just before he made his ML debut, though he continued to see reps at SS. Maybe I'm forgotten, but wwre there any complaints or articles last season about him not being able to play 3B adequately? I don't recall any. Now that he's struggled with some throws, he's questionable at 3B or anywhere else? He's missed an awful lot of time. Time that allows him to play consecutively for a period of time at 3B. His throwing motion, for whatever reason, had suddenly gotten out of whack despite being a former SS who's also played some 3B. Hmmmm....couldn't he put in some work and get his throwing motion back in line? Wow! An amazing concept! A good athlete who's played the left side of the INF his whole life gets some "yips" but can put in work to correct that? Who knew? Lewis is not moving off 3B any time soon. He has everything in his tool box to be a dangerous hitter and quality defender. He just needs to polish to throwing.

First thing I thought was "OF COURSE!" While disappointing as can be, not only could McCarthy's injury have been worse, or at a worse time, but he was going to sit most of the season no matter what. Once upon a time, your young QB used to sit for a year or two behind a veteran to learn the system and adjust to the league. Patrick Mahomes...arguably the best player/QB in the league...sat for all but 1 game his rookie season. What stinks is the on the field practice time he's going to miss. He can still watch film, attend all meetings, and absorb that way. If he's placed on the IL he's out for the season. And I don't believe he would be allowed any sort of actual "practice" time even if he heals up quickly. If he makes the opening day roster and then isnplaced on the IL, he can be brought back later, if he heals quickly, to at least get some non-contact practice reps around December. Just something to think about.