When Buxton is confident at the plate, there are few players in the whole sport that are better. That would be immensely valuable in the ALCS or the World Series. However, when he is not, he strikes out over and over again.
It’s hard to see a clear path in which he gets enough plate appearances to gain the confidence he needs. The best scenario would be if Lewis is healthy enough to play at 3B, and then he could start vs a LH at DH (let’s say…Martin Perez?), and be a PH option for Wallner or Kiriloff. Would he be a better option than Solano or Farmer or Castro in those PH situations? Not sure. But if he did well in a DH start…maybe?
In any event, I don’t think the Twins will make the decision based on sentimentality. Whatever the case, I certainly hope there is a decision to make about whether to roster him for the ALCS and beyond!