It is pretty amazing how well some people can successfully "guess" when someone is lying. It is quite a talent, actually. Children, spouses, co-workers....... sometimes the evidence is in the expressions, micro-expressions, and other behavior, and conclusions correct, regardless whether it meets the "court of law test", which certainly isn't the greatest test, as history has shown. I cannot make a judgement on the "hitting and choking" his girlfriend accusation, as there was absolutely no physical evidence reported able to be collected to substantiate that claim, and that was immediately after the incident happened. Not all states allow one to shoot a gun inside a house when not in self defense (crazy Florida lets you have a shooting range on residential property!) Shooting the gun, even alone in the garage with the other people around....... that is just nuts and certainly would intimidate me, and I would be leaving immediately if not sooner. Chapman sure can pitch, and that is not a guess.