It makes for an interesting thought experiment.
Would you trade Berrios's remaining team control for two years of Sonny Gray (as they were scouted at the time, or as their respective seasons played out)?
Would you trade Chase Petty for SWR and Austin Martin (as they were scouted at the time, or as their respective seasons played out)?
This prompted me to check in again on Petty. I wasn't aware that he has resurfaced in the majors, after a rough introduction. His last 10 games, all in relief during garbage time in blowouts, show a 2.76 ERA across 16.1 innings. FIP is a little less kind at 3.63. He's 23 and getting his feet wet in the majors. Much as I cherish the personal memories of the 2023 post-season series against Toronto, I'm not quite ready to close the books on the Sonny Gray trade,
Anyway, both my imaginary trades are a lot harder for me to decide on than I expected. With perfect hindsight, I see the "trade" of the two major leaguers as approximately a wash, and of the prospects I'd certainly like to still have Petty instead of the two washouts. But trades actually have to be made without hindsight, and I bought into SWR's promise.