Contract extensions are about cost certainty and trying to avoid future contracts that only a handful of teams can afford, like the Yankees and Dodgers. The players get life changing dollars, even if their careers go sideways or they get hurt. It can be a win win for mid market teams. So it can make sense, like it did for Polanco and Kepler, both good decisions.
I don’t see Ryan as having the upside of an ace, but I think he can be a consistent 15 game winner with an ERA below 3.0, assuming Rocco lets him pitch deeper into games, which isn’t a given. And Ober seems to have FINALLY gained Rocco’s trust, and is pitching six innings and beyond on a consistent basis. So despite the negative comments here, I can see these two as extension candidates because starting pitching is the most difficult thing to develop. Lewis has shown us his potential, despite his injuries and poor production during the last six weeks of 2024. So an extension isn’t a ridiculous move. A Jeffers extension is more complicated, IMO. But he is a major league catcher with power, and has shown the potential on both sides of the plate, despite his fall off last year. So I don’t think he’s a candidate for an extension right now.