Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted

I’m curious your thoughts here; let’s say the Twins were to trade Joe Ryan to Boston. And all you knew was that Tristan Casas was part of the package coming back. My question is, would you like it? Hate it?

And if that is part of it, how much else would have to be added to Casas for it to be a fair deal?

I ask because IF he is healthy I do think Casas is a middle of the order type bat and he is only 26. I’ve always liked him, but he is hurt a lot.

Posted

Tristan Casas is a throw in right now. He has burned his years of control on the injured list. He's Arb 2 at a very low Arb 2 figure but he's arb 2. You get him for this year and one more. You'd be hoping that he rebounded enough in 2027 to have actual trade value going into his final arb 3 year. 

How much would Boston have to add to a deal? Almost the entire amount of the trade. Casas is a throw in. His health has been off the charts not good. He is arb two and less then 1,000 AB's. That's 4 years wasted just getting to 1,000. For a comparable think Byron Buxton in 2018. 

With that said... I wouldn't hate it if they took a flyer on Casas.

Despite a really crappy year in 2025 before blowing a tendon to end 2025. 2026 was stopped by two seperate injuries (ab and wrist) that took out all of 2026.

Yet... His career OPS still sits at .800. Boston will have to turn him loose unless they are planning a trade of Contreras. 

I really don't see a Joe Ryan trade with Boston.

Unless they overpaid... like trading Jake Bennett for Joe Ryan.

If the Red Sox traded Jake Bennett and Tristan Casas for Joe Ryan... Sign me up on Jake Bennett alone. 

He's a potential King Kong Bat. I wouldn't hate it. It's just that... I would have rather had Bauers. 

 

Posted
10 hours ago, Cory Engelhardt said:

I’m curious your thoughts here; let’s say the Twins were to trade Joe Ryan to Boston. And all you knew was that Tristan Casas was part of the package coming back. My question is, would you like it? Hate it?

And if that is part of it, how much else would have to be added to Casas for it to be a fair deal?

I ask because IF he is healthy I do think Casas is a middle of the order type bat and he is only 26. I’ve always liked him, but he is hurt a lot.

Hate it.  Another band aid at best and highly speculative.  It's time to follow practices that can produce sustained success.  This is not it.

Posted
3 minutes ago, Mike Sixel said:

He's not good. What is the obsession with this guy?

He was really good when he last played, and he is set to play winter ball. I’m curious how he will look 

Posted

Tristan Casas will most likely be a free agent this coming Saturday. His agent will talk with teams who might have a lane for him to get back to the majors and he will sign a minor league contract with a Spring Training invite.

If you look over the Red Sox roster, this seems like a no brainer. Why pay him $2M when they have no position or plans for him. Right now the Red Sox are trying to trade Casas. Cole Sands for Tristan Casas would be a fair deal.

 

Posted
12 minutes ago, tony&rodney said:

Tristan Casas will most likely be a free agent this coming Saturday. His agent will talk with teams who might have a lane for him to get back to the majors and he will sign a minor league contract with a Spring Training invite.

If you look over the Red Sox roster, this seems like a no brainer. Why pay him $2M when they have no position or plans for him. Right now the Red Sox are trying to trade Casas. Cole Sands for Tristan Casas would be a fair deal.

 

Yeah this makes sense. I would be interested in this. Scratch including Ryan here

Posted
2 minutes ago, Cory Engelhardt said:

Yeah this makes sense. I would be interested in this. Scratch including Ryan here

While it is easy to understand that Joe Ryan does not hold or carry the value he had last winter, I believe he is highly underrated on Twins Daily. Taj Bradley had a really good year but Joe Ryan is still projected to be the Twins Opening Day starter at this moment in time. Ryan is really good. 

Posted
6 minutes ago, tony&rodney said:

While it is easy to understand that Joe Ryan does not hold or carry the value he had last winter, I believe he is highly underrated on Twins Daily. Taj Bradley had a really good year but Joe Ryan is still projected to be the Twins Opening Day starter at this moment in time. Ryan is really good. 

You think so? I’d absolutely put Taj there. Whatever spring training looks like will be interesting 

Posted
1 minute ago, Cory Engelhardt said:

You think so? I’d absolutely put Taj there. Whatever spring training looks like will be interesting 

Definitely.

There is a strong chance Ryan is traded. One can only hope that if Ryan is traded the return is noteworthy.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Twins community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...