Déjà Vu in the North: How 2025 Twins Echo Their 2023 Blueprint

[Cody Christie]

Image courtesy of © Jesse Johnson-Imagn Images

As the Minnesota Twins approach the summer months of the 2025 season, fans are experiencing a sense of déjà vu. The team's current trajectory mirrors the 2023 season, with a formidable pitching staff carrying the load while the offense struggles to find its rhythm.

Pitching: The Backbone Remains Strong
In 2023, the Twins' rotation was anchored by Pablo López and Sonny Gray, both of whom delivered impressive performances. López posted an 11-8 record with a 3.66 ERA over 194 innings, while Gray contributed a stellar 2.79 ERA across 32 starts. Gray finished runner-up to Gerrit Cole for the AL Cy Young Award, while López was electric during the team’s playoff run. His dominant start in Houston is a legendary moment for the current generation of Twins fans.

Fast-forward to 2025, and López continues to be a cornerstone of the rotation. Through nine starts, he boasts a 2.31 ERA and 54 strikeouts over 50 2/3 innings. Joe Ryan has emerged as a top-of-the-rotation arm, with a 2.68 ERA and 67 strikeouts in 57 innings. Bailey Ober had a disastrous first start (8 ER in 2 2/3 IP) but has settled in nicely, with a 2.28 ERA and 43 strikeouts over his last 55 1/3 innings. Minnesota’s 2025 rotation might be stronger and deeper than the 2023 club's. 

The bullpen was projected to be among the league’s best this season. However, some early-season blowups put that projected performance into question. During the team’s recent winning stretch, the bullpen has seen improved performance. In May, the team’s top four bullpen arms (Jhoan Duran, Cole Sands, Griffin Jax, and Louis Varland) have all provided a 0.54 win probability added (WPA) or higher. Out of that group, Varland has the highest May ERA with a 1.74 mark, while Sands and Duran are below 0.80. It’s been an amazing stretch. 

Offensive Struggles: A Familiar Story
The 2023 Twins faced offensive challenges, ranking in the bottom half of the league in several key categories. The 2025 lineup is experiencing similar issues. As of late May, the team ranks 21st in SLG and wOBA. There may be some signs of a turnaround, with the team ranking in the top 10 for Hard Hit%, but runs have been hard to come by even in their recent winning streak. 

Injuries have played a significant role. Byron Buxton (concussion) and Matt Wallner (hamstring) are expected to return during the current road trip, potentially providing a much-needed boost. However, recent returnees like Royce Lewis and Willi Castro have yet to regain their form. Lewis is hitting .148/.212/.230, while being worth -0.2 WAR. Castro, after returning from an oblique strain, has posted an 84 OPS+, which is 18 points lower than he had in 2024. Lewis and Castro don’t need to carry the lineup, but they need to provide competitive at-bats.

Youth Movement: A Potential Spark
In 2023, the infusion of young talent ignited the offense in the second half, featuring players such as Royce Lewis, Matt Wallner, and Edouard Julien. This trio propelled the Twins to their first playoff series win since the early 2000s.

The 2025 squad may find similar rejuvenation from emerging players. Luke Keaschall made an immediate impact, before a fractured right forearm sidelined him. He's expected to return in late June, offering hope for a second-half surge.

Emmanuel Rodriguez, one of the organization's top prospects, has been honing his skills at Triple-A St. Paul. Despite past injury concerns, his recent performance suggests he's nearing MLB readiness. After a slow start, Rodriguez has posted a 1.028 OPS during May, indicating his potential to contribute at the major-league level.

Brooks Lee, while no longer a rookie, continues to develop into a key offensive piece. His 2025 metrics show a Hard Hit% of 38% and an expected slugging percentage (.xSLG) of .406, 50 points higher than his actual slugging percentage, suggesting positive regression is on the horizon. Minnesota has already trusted Lee with batting in the middle of the lineup, so look to him as a player to provide more offense as he settles into being a big-league regular. 

The Twins' recent turnaround has put them back in the thick of the playoff race, but the team still has flaws. The team's success hinges on the offense's ability to complement the stellar pitching staff. The upcoming returns of Buxton and Wallner, coupled with the potential impact of Keaschall, Rodriguez, and Lee, could provide the necessary spark.

As the season progresses, the Twins must address their offensive woes to capitalize on their pitching prowess. If history is any indication, a midseason youth infusion could once again be the catalyst for a playoff push.

---

Which player will provide the biggest offensive spark? Can the 2025 Twins follow the exact blueprint as the 2023 Twins? Leave a comment and start the discussion.

View full article

[LambchoP]

While Keaschal, Buxton and Wallner should definitely help the offense, I think the season long struggles of Lewis, Castro and Lee will even things out. Our pitching has been great, although with Coloumbe going down the depth of our bullpen, especially lefties, is beginning to show. Unless the team figures out how to start scoring runs, I could see a big drop in the standings coming...

[DJL44]

I think Wallner could provide the big boost they need.

The positions that have underperformed the most are 3B, 2B and 1B. Lewis can play a helluva lot better than he's playing right now. Castro and Lee haven't been great at the plate but they're doing a lot better than Lewis.

 

[Major League Ready]

Lee has never provided any offense and Castro had a wRC+ of 87 the second half of last season so it’s been awhile since he has been part of the solution.  Lewis was also horrible the 2nd half.  The three guys that carried the offense last year were Wallner, Buxton, and Correa.  None of them are contributing right now and that’s why the offense is relatively unproductive.

Wallner and Buxton were looking good prior to going out.  It would seem they are the most likely players to boost the offense.  Correa seems like the next most likely.  He is simply better than he has been playing.  I am not sure what to make of Lewis but this will be a different team if 2 or 3 of these four can perform consistent with their ability.

Keaschall is the 2nd half wild card.  He looked great but he was not around long enough to find out what happens when pitchers adjust.  

[NYCTK]

4 hours ago, DJL44 said:

I think Wallner could provide the big boost they need.

The positions that have underperformed the most are 3B, 2B and 1B. Lewis can play a helluva lot better than he's playing right now. Castro and Lee haven't been great at the plate but they're doing a lot better than Lewis.

 

Lewis has a .292 wOBA in the last calendar year. Compare that to Jonah Bride with a .321 wOBA in that same time frame. Wowsers.