I don’t know for certain or not if Donaldson was a negative on the team chemistry. Possibly. He could have been part of the whole with that. Sometimes players and personalities just don’t blend. It’s interesting to see the turn around this year. Kepler commented that they just didn’t blend last year, they weren’t a team, just a bunch of individuals, but I’ve not heard a single report specifically pointing to Donaldson as the cause. Just a lot of scapegoating from Twins Daily, imo.
At the time I liked the signing. Without any hindsight applied, I still like the signing. The Twins showed a commitment to signing a big name. We needed better defense at third and we needed a bat to replace the bats that were leaving after 2019. We needed more fire and personality. I thought the Twins were making a commitment to better the team. I still think that, even though it didn’t work out as hoped. Of course, in HINDSIGHT, it didn’t work out the way I think anyone hoped for various reasons. Part of that wasn’t Donaldson’s fault, because pitching didn’t do us any favors. If I knew all of that before, no I don’t sign him, then what? No way to know for certain if we’d be better off today or not. We got good pieces in return so it wasn’t a total loss. So, maybe there was something worthwhile. But I don’t think it was the worst signing ever. Far from that, even though it didn’t work out as hoped.