'23 might be the high-water mark for this roster group, but your HOF SS had the worst season, by bWAR, of his career. What they got was career years from Jeffers, Castro, Julien, Lewis, Farmer, Wallner, and Solano; a big bounce back year from Kepler, and solid, steady play from MAT in CF. Polanco, despite injuries, was on pace for the third-best bWAR season of his career. They also had very solid SP, with five guys making at least 20 starts (of those, only Ryan had an ERA+ that was less than league average (97)), and had the second most bWAR in MLB (Ober had the highest bWAR in his career, Gray and Lopez each had the second best bWAR of their careers). They also had an above average BP (Duran, Pagan, and Stewart were very good), with the seventh best bWAR in MLB that season.
They need a lot of things to go their way to have a successful '26 season by W-L record, but player development could be big the season.