They need to find three or four starting pitchers next off season.... Given their fiscal restraint, would you rather downgrade first, or spend less on pitching? They will likely need relief pitching also.
It's like margin of error doesn't exist all of a sudden.... But let's set aside if he's replacement level, or close... He's not good. He's ok. Which was the actual point of the post that started this tangent. I hope the find someone better, or much cheaper so they upgrade someplace else.
Actually, one fWAR is replacement level, unless you think it is that precise over a full year..... As for his defense, that is what people said about Mauer. First base defense is just not that hard to find.
I like this a lot more than when it was first announced, and it was only Romo coming back. It's a fine, not exciting, idea to trade minor league depth for an ok RP and a minor league pitcher. Just do two more things....
If they can get a controllable starter, they should. Sixty percent of the rotation will be free agents, and does anyone trust the fourth guy all that much beyond this year? They are below last year's budget. The fans are showing up. If not now, when?
As a short stop......97 wrc+ in the majors is median for a SS. And for a 2B. Not saying he could do that, but if he stayed around 95, he'd be median to just worse than that for a SS, and median for a 2B (SS are hitting better than 2B this year).
Remember when entire said they could trade Gordon, because Lewis and Javier were locks to be here in the next year or two? Good times. I'd be careful dealing Gordon at this point. I'd do it for the right player, but I'd be careful.