It would have made a modicum of sense to draft a QB that needed development time (Maye or McCarthy), but Penix is not that guy. He should be ready to start early in 2024 but now it's going to be 2026 at soonest.
Age does matter less, but his body has endured 2 ACL tears to the same knee and a torn labrum. Maye and McCarthy have no injury histories and are likely to last longer in the league.
There are things to like about Penix and that's why I had him mocked to the Raiders at #13, but that was to immediately battle Minshew for the starting job. The Falcons passed up the best defensive player in the draft or even moving down 4-6 spots and STILL landing the best defensive player in the draft and instead are now paying something like $53M a year on their QB room without having a surefire top 5 QB on the roster. And their edge room is pretty bad and they really could have used Latu/Verse/Turner. This is beyond baffling.
Bears and Lions made very smart moves, I have to give them credit. Caleb Williams is walking into a good environment and the Lions attacked their biggest weakness (CB). The Packers pick is fine, but they had a 7th rounder playing good enough at LT so I thought they'd go DeJean or Barton.
The fans overrate him, but what are you getting in return for a matchup-centric ILB and how are you replacing him? I see no reason to get rid of one of Flores' favorite chess pieces.
Not sure you'd get even that for Bradbury (Ezra Cleveland only got us a 6th and he's considerably better)... and I'd love to do it but LG is a bigger problem. My guess is they move on from Bradbury in 2025.