I'm glad I went to college, and I can't deny a competitive aspect to my schooling (dating back at least to Kindergarten - I have been hard to be around at any age ). Somehow I didn't catch on that that was the value you were driving at, as a way for one individual to leapfrog other individuals in our various social castes. But I don't see college as being valuable for its exclusivity. It's valuable if it teaches the most, to the most people. Now, I do agree with the mild backlash that trade schools should be given more emphasis than they get now. And I am not in favor of kids lingering in school just to delay their eventual emergence into the workforce. But the world today has too much going on to get all the important stuff across by age 18. If you've got anything on the ball, we're all better off if you keep at your schooling. I got so angry when Senator Santorum during a campaign speech railed against Obama for some kind of "college for all" proposal back in the day. "What... a... SNOB!" he said snidely. That POV intentionally misses the point in order to stoke resentment.