Above average, no. That's pretty elite company. Last year the guys who did that were named Judge (overachieving this by just a bit ), Goldschmidt, Y Alvarez, Soto, and Freeman. I took a look at those guys' minor league records and, without getting lost in the weeds too much, none of them had the low-BA high-OBP profile that our ERod does. I don't know who/what the comp for ERod should be, because he's pretty unique. But he's not hitting .300 in the minors like these top hitters were at similar times.
The huge walk rate suggests an ability to wait for his pitch and then really wallop it, or else accept the walk if the pitcher won't pitch to him. And certainly the HR power is legit, but the low batting average is what's puzzling to me. The other explanation I can come up with is that there is a profile of pitches he just doesn't feel like he can handle, and at the minor league levels he's been at he's been able to spit on borderline pitches in those areas and deal with the ones he prefers. As he moves up, the pitchers get better and better at hitting their spots, and if he really has a hole in his swing somewhere, those pitchers will be able to exploit it more and more.
Or he could, you know, learn to hit those pitches he currently doesn't feel comfortable with. I just don't know.
It's a drum I try not to bang too often. I wouldn't trade him, he's too intriguing for that. But I'm very much an ERod skeptic. He doesn't have a lot of strong comps, which makes him a very interesting unicorn to watch. But it's an open question to me whether those huge numbers of walks remain walks, turn into hits, or turn into outs, as he moves up.
What's the chance he turns into Joey Gallo? A lifetime OBP of only .325 or so, built with lots of walks on top of a low BA? An "above-average regular" (in his prime) who everyone loves to hate and everyone keeps waiting for a peak that never arrives?