tony&rodney

I keep remembering the Santana situation. I argued then that unless the Twins received a haul, the team would be better off with Johan pitching for the Twins. A trade of Buxton for players we already have and sticking Cave in CF hold no appeal. I agree with everything you said except I am willing to just see Buxton excel during the coming year for the Twins, even if he moves on to another team thereafter.

Shifting to the morose trade aspect of this debacle, we have to wonder what is available right now from another team. Is it another Joe Ryan? Does anyone have any thoughts? The suggestions from BTV, thus far, just add to our 40 person roster dilemmas or give us another ok (mediocre) guy like Urshela. Thoughts?

Really he has less than one year. Glasnow is out next year and will be rebounding from surgery in 2023. The idea of multiple trades to re-boot the pitching staff still seems plausible but Falvey may not have any plans to rebuild quickly. We are a confused fan base right now.

All of this ^ I dont under stand how no one else is seeing it this way. Completely agree. Well, here is an attempt at a short explanation. There is not a single prospect in baseball that has the combination of talents of Byron Buxton. He has a history of missing games though. Thus, the Twins will not return a single player from a trade of Byron who makes the Twins appreciably better now or in the future because teams will not risk sending their talent for an expensive one year oft-injured player. Byron Buxton has much more value to the Twins than to another team because without him the rebuild begins. Most Twins fans do not wish to watch or listen to a team that spends the next five years losing 90-120 games. Buxton might return a Trevor Larnach or Joe Ryan type player, but not multiples of those. These players are decent but will never reach the heights of Buxton. If you just want to rebuild, every player on the team making more than $1 million goes and in 5-7 years the Twins may or may not have a good team. Check on Baltimore. Your position is not irrational or uncommon, but those of us who watch most or nearly all of the Twins games have watched many dozens of prospects fail (Willie Banks, Joe Benson) and recognize the value of what is in hand. I hope you can see the keep Buxton side of an argument, even if you still don't believe in him.

You do make a valid point. Polanco is the Twins MVP and the most likely to bring back a good package of players or a pitcher. This would, however, signal a five year rebuilding plan. At that point one could then argue that Kepler, Rogers, Duffey, Sano, and Donaldson should all be traded for prospects. The payroll could be #25 million too. The Twins are currently about in the middle rankings of the MLB farm systems, but these trades would move them towards the top of team prospect rankings. I don't think this is a feasible idea. i do think Polanco is a real gem.

Guess who owns the bank? Or is that what you meant? I missed the sarcasm somehow.

Buxton - no way. Falvey - why? Buxton could retire today and never look back. The Twins absolutely need Buxton. You only need to look at the W-L records of the Twins with and without Buxton. Tickets, ad sales, viewership - there is a ton on the line here. The Twins did not average as many fans last season as the Timberwolves drew to last night's game. The T-Wolves are terrible. Is that acceptable? We are all human and Falvey has misspoken. I will hope that things will take a turn for the positive.

The Twins have backed themselves into a corner. Perhaps their best option is to just sign him for 2022 and let him become a free agent.

Agreed. Just frustration with all of the news/articles today. Maybe Stroman can happen.

I appreciate this response and I'm inclined to always pick the Twins to win the World Series every year. However, Berrios at $11 m. for 2022 and then 6/$120 was way too much for the Twins? How do the Twins then turn and sign Stroman for 5/$125 or more? The optics and timing of the Berrios signing does throw some shade on us optimists. It is a real "hmmm?".

This Buxton situation has completely stymied the Twins front office apparently. "I'm having a really hard time connecting the dots here." - This is almost everyone, both Twins fans and those who follow baseball around the country. Something is amiss and it is frustrating to wait for the other shoe to fall. As to the possibilities .... it seems what numbers were shared/published are likely real or quite close. The other three possibilities seem much more to the heart of the problem in signing Buxton: the Twins don't believe in Byron, he is ready to move, and the Twins do not intend to pay for a Buxton contract. Whew, this is too much to get our head around. I mean the Twins could put a team on the field that does better than last year's record for $100 million. That team would need to include Buxton, even if the bill for BB was $25 million (a quarter of the payroll). Without Buxton, the Twins need to go into a full rebuild like Baltimore or boost the payroll to $150 million. So many posts and the article in The Athletic puts a new twist in our expectations/hopes for Twins baseball. How is it possible that Falvey is still analyzing their own roster and wondering what to do? The quote from The Athletic was somewhat disturbing. “Now, we’re working through understanding all sides of this ultimately. We’ll proceed accordingly. At this stage of the offseason, we’re still just navigating our strategy and planning and trying to understand what’s available to us and what the market looks like on all periods. As is always the case, this isn’t unique to Byron or otherwise, there are people on our team that are interesting to other clubs and we just always need to work through what does that look like, what does our team look like as we navigate it.” This entire past year has been confusing. My default is to accept what Falvey sees as best for making the Twins competitive, even when I disagree. The unfolding of this drama with Buxton causes me to question. Yah, what the hell is going on?

Would 5/$125 meet a bar for BB? So may ideas and no movement since July. One wonders whether the Twins do not view Byron as worth a contract or that Buxton is ready to play on different team.

They are the most uninteresting team in baseball.

The Twins need to make a decision on Buxton. They have options: 1) offer Buxton whatever he wants; 2) sign him for 2022 and make the team very competitive in hopes he will sign later in the year; or 3) trade Buxton. My choices are the first two but it is entirely possible that Byron has already decided that he will not be returning as a Twin after 2022 no matter what circumstances play out. In that case, a trade will happen eventually, either soon or during the year. Perhaps a healthy productive Buxton becomes really attractive to a team doing well and willing to gamble that they can sign him because he is healthy and killing it in June.

This is so true. A subscription to mlb.com that is used is fair entertainment value. There are some fun teams and players to follow. Ohtani and Trout are amazing to watch. The Twins have been my team since they moved here in 1961 and my attention to their games will continue no matter the outcome of this offseason. However, I did have season tickets once upon a time and have attended a ton of games in the past. The expenditures of going to a game in person is not something I consider when the team is substandard. I just enjoy the game situations via radio and follow players on mlb.com. The Twins still have time for abundant moves this winter.

It is a little early to become overwrought with the state of the Twins. That said, it gets early sooner in the winter. The time to analyze the roster was in October and those teams with any interest in any Twins assets have already communicated their thoughts. The next week should be interesting because the window before Thanksgiving and then the end of the CBA starting on 1 December is prime trading season. There may be plans to budget closer to $100 million for 2022. Buxton may be put on the to-do list, later. The Twins have some decent bats growing: Jeffers, Kirilloff, Larnach, Rooker, Celestino, Lewis, Martin, Miranda, and perhaps someone else. Pitching prospects include: Ryan, Ober, Dobnak, Barnes, Jax, Thorpe, Smeltzer, Duran, Winder, Balazovic, Woods-Richardson, and some others. Perhaps Falvey has confidence in their current hand. I would still bank on a few trades and a couple of signings, not the team below.

I thought the same thing. Bundy, Cobb, Pineda, etc. are all seemingly the potential additions via free agency. If the Twins cannot sign a Berrios for that contract or gamble on a Syndergaard, the options are going to be limited in free agency. This leaves trades as the only viable option before dipping to a rebuilding plan. There are still options but today was not so cheerful for Twins fans, except that we should be happy for Jose.

Twins fans love all three of these players. It is likely that a poll would value Garver and Arraez above Kepler. Personally, i like all three. However, the Twins have zero experienced pitchers heading into next season. The free agent market will not fill all of their needs, thus a few trades need to be completed. Regrettably, I would use both Garver and Arraez in trades. Kepler is a good outfielder and I'm interested in the Twins improving their defense, so i keep Kepler. That said, if Kepler is the player that returns a strong starting pitcher then even Magic Max goes. Parting with any of these players would be tough and if there was a way to find four pitchers without trading .... ok. I cannot configure any semblance of a decent roster for 2022 that does not include at least one significant trade.

Hmmm .... to be a fly on the wall. Apparently, Berrios did not meet some criteria for Falvey. 7/$131 is pretty close to the 5/$125 expected by several current free agents. I wonder what specific points clogged up negotiations between Berrios and the Twins. Stuff happens. Congratulations to Jose Berrios and his family and the Toronto Blue Jays. i hope this works well for all.

Yes, the Twins could swing a deal and they also should. Oakland has two pitchers to go after right now. There isn't any reason to wait. The prospect package for Bassitt, if amenable to Oakland, should be finished. Montas - yes. Why not both. TopGun#22 is right. The Twins need four decent starting pitchers. Miami, Oakland, and Milwaukee have pieces and the longer the Twins wait the more likely another team swoops in and completes a deal. Oakland is a particularly good trade partner for those who refuse to consider a trade of either Garver or Jeffers. Like others, Larnach is a player I'm hoping will interest Miami. Still, Bassitt is someone we could use this year as the inexperienced pitchers transition to the MLB hitters.

Detroit identified what they wanted and could do and then did it. I have made a few lists myself and was influenced by a recent post to add Rodriguez. I wrote his salary down as $17 million. He's gone and it is reasonable to rotate to Jon Gray. Stroman and Gausman seem a little rich, but why not hold out hope for one of these pitchers. Trades are still available but I'm hoping that movement is sooner than later because so many teams are looking for pitchers, it seems like the best will be spoken for by December 1.

Nick, your post was fair and timely. The front office has done some good things with player acquisition and it should be acknowledged. Drowning in tears is not going to make anyone feel better or improve the roster. Now, the Twins are put to the task. They need to identify targets. I would argue they need to expand a little. It is understandable that many are not in favor of trading any prospects but other teams will only consider a few Twins players as worthy of an exchange. Free agency should be useful for a player or two, but it is essential to add at least one or two decent starting pitchers to lead the Twins young starters in their initiation into MLB action. Many have suggested a contract for Jon Gray and we now have an example of what it will take to sign such a player. The Twins could offer Gray exactly what Rodriguez just received from Detroit. Gray, Pineda, a trade with Miami, Oakland, or another team - the time is ripe. Great back and forth conversation by TD readers.

My hope was to pry away Alcantara and Meyer by enticing Miami with Lewis, in addition to Larnach, their choice of catcher, Canterino, and Strotman or Vallimont. Miami is not likely to give up Alcantara and the Twins do not want to part with Lewis, so the trade above by TopGun#22 is a huge boost for both Miami and Minnesota. It is cost effective for both teams too and allows both teams to consider buying a free agent or two. Suddenly, Gray, Pineda, and possibly Stroman are fits in a fair budget. The post was asking about Jeffers though and he is going to be a very decent MLB catcher. I have no concerns about his bat and am sure he will continue to improve as a catcher. I'm a little confused how someone can be down on him after just a year and a half. Catcher is far and away the most demanding and difficult position in baseball and he has held his own as a young player. If he remains a Twin, I am excited to see his continued growth. I will add that I may be higher than some others on Ben Rortvedt, especially his glove and arm. BR does need another half to full year of development however.

This is exactly what I was thinking. All of the reports were positive and incentives should be a win, win. My addition, totally speculative, is that Buxton wants to see what the Twins are going to do this offseason to address the team. Again, I just threw that out there. Sometimes there are players who want their contracts completed by Thanksgiving. This clears the holidays from distractions, questions, and allows for a breather in what can be a long year.

Excellent debate and good comments as well.