Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

tony&rodney

Verified Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    9,764

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    86

 Content Type 

Profiles

News

Minnesota Twins Videos

2026 Minnesota Twins Top Prospects Ranking

2022 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks

Minnesota Twins Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits

Guides & Resources

2023 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks

The Minnesota Twins Players Project

2024 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks

2025 Minnesota Twins Draft Pick Tracker

2026 Minnesota Twins Draft Pick Tracker

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by tony&rodney

  1. tony&rodney
    We are on Page 3 of comments on a nothing trade. Falvey & Sons may have been purposely done putting this roster together last offseason. We are stooges just goofing around having a little fun in our spare time with an entertainment that helps us avoid the continuing tragedies in our world. Thank you Twins Daily.
  2. tony&rodney
    I agree. First thought though - name a modern Philly shortstop that hit .200 but had a top glove. I don't believe the Phillies placed much value on Caba. Second though - Gabriel gonzalez was in Top 100 slots last year. Have you seen him play? I like to watch the players and place very little status in bottom 100 prospects.
  3. tony&rodney
    Makes one wonder whether it is better to give those lost plate appearances to EmRod, Keaschall, Eeles, and others versus relying on Gallo, Margot, etc.
  4. tony&rodney
    What would we do? Clearly, the Twins did not want Luzardo. The Phillies don't roster good field/no hit players so the prospect (Caba) that went to the Marlins was an infield reverse of who Gabriel Gonzalez (good hit/no field OF) was last offseason. In other words, not too valuable. Culpepper is worth slightly more at this time although he is not ranked. In any respect, the Marlins were just dumping Luzardo.
  5. tony&rodney
    Uh, Cleveland has Jose Ramirez on their team. You would have an easier team getting Judge or Soto. Redo.
  6. tony&rodney
    K. Culpepper already has received a fair amount of respect. MLB.com has him as the Twins #4 prospect now. I guess you are wondering why Twins Daily writers put Kaelen lower. I don't know. The contact/ ability to hit and arm strength are clear strengths, but Culpepper is not a speedster, has not hit with power, and his glove has yet to be lauded on any level. There is a good chance that Kaelen has himself a decent MLB career as a 2B/3B or strong utility player. The Twins clearly like him. As a first round draft choice he will receive a ton of opportunities to show his skill and this year will answer some questions about how the young infielder adapts to a higher level of professional baseball. I'm looking forward to watching him play next summer. I don't believe he is underrated at this time.
  7. tony&rodney
    I agree that Diaz would help the lineup and lengthen the lineup. I disagree that the Twins cannot afford Diaz or others. It is a choice. There have been and still are options. I believe, until proven wrong, that Falvey has his team exactly as it is currently rostered. Money has nothing to do with it. Falvey has said that on numerous occasions and we have seen how the team has backed its players and let trade opportunities slide away. The Twins like what they have. Nothing wrong with that. Roll it back and expect improvements through experience, etc. This (at this time) looks like the plan. Has anyone heard anything to suggest anything different?
  8. tony&rodney
    It didn't only look bad last season, it was in actual real time reality just plain poor. So yeah, something needs to give and break differently in 2025 with this group. Thing is, you just never know.
  9. tony&rodney
    This was my very first thought seeing the title (Wallner) ... what you said. Falvey has his team. Our thoughts and attempts to tweak the roster were pointless similar to all references to payroll. The roster was already on board. In addition to Lewis, Larnach, and Wallner, it will be important to receive productive rebounds from at least two of Miranda, Julien, and Lee along with continued health from our catchers. While I would love to see Emmanuel Rodriguez and maybe even Luke Keaschall on Opening Day, the Twins will hold them in AAA until at least late May but still hope to get key contributions from the rookies in 2025. The Twins currently rostered will get their shot at proving their worth and that is what every baseball player ever wants, opportunity.
  10. tony&rodney
    Baltimore has a few prospects (Basallo & Mayo), but I'm not really interested in either one of those guys for Pablo Lopez. I think Falvey is unplugged; he has his team. It has nothing to do with money. He just wants to see what his guys can do next season.
  11. tony&rodney
    The Red Sox are done shopping for pitchers, so Twins fans can rest easy on Pablo Lopez. The trading scenarios are dwindling, which might be a good thing.
  12. tony&rodney
    One of the reasons I like Lewis at 1B is because I believe it would free three things: Lewis' mind and the ability to possibly trade both Julien and Miranda who I think still have value. Miranda and Varland to Seattle for Harry Ford Duran, Castro, and Kyle DeBarge to Arizona for Jordan Lawler Brooks Lee to Milwaukee for Jeferson Quero Sign Julio Iglesias for $2-4M Trade Chris Paddack Maybe something like SWR, Julien, Topa, Vazquez, and $3M in international bonus money to San Diego for Dylan Cease Just some talent added. Sadly, the Twins may already have their roster and it is not a bad team. As is: Lewis, Castro, Lee, Correa, Larnach (EmRod here), Buck, Wallner along with the others and catchers.
  13. tony&rodney
    Love that you are proposing ideas to improve the Twins roster. My opinions below are just that, mine. They are not criticisms. You asked and I'm answering. #1 The Twins say no. Casas is a DH who cannot run, field, or throw. That makes him about as valuable as Jose Miranda, who is already on the team. If the Red Sox sign Bregman, I think the Twins could acquire Casas for Miranda and Matthews. I'm high on Matthews and would not trade him. #2 The Marlins say no. Sandy Alcantara would command either a better player than Brooks Lee or a set of a couple of Julien(Miranda and Paddack) plus 3-4 prospects along the lines (or better) than Gonzalez. #3 Both Scherzer and Verlander say no. These guys have made a boatload of money playing baseball and will be very select about where they go. Unfortunately, this excludes the Twins. I wish Verlander could make a miraculous return as a Twins but no way it happens.
  14. tony&rodney
    Billy Amick could well be a guy who hits a ton. He may also be a very good add-on in a trade.
  15. tony&rodney
    If your goal is to acquire Tristan Casas, Duran is enough on his own. If you want to send Vazquez away in the deal, just add Varland or Topa. If you think Boston wants Miranda and Matthews and you want to send off Vazquez you add either Varland or Topa. Your deal is a pretty big overpay in talent. I understand that many feel that MLB may be too tough for Zebby Matthews but I'm thinking he will really develop in the next year plus. Zooming from A+ to MLB was a pretty drastic experience last summer. i would not trade Matthews for Casas. Again, I'm not high on DH only players, Casas does have a big bat for home runs, ala Matt Wallner. Wallner can run and throw and is much more athletic which gives me hope he will improve defensively. So we will disagree on Casas which is part of these discussions. I really think Royce Lewis would be a terrific first baseman.
  16. tony&rodney
    I think the Guards would suggest that their loss at 2B is made whole by the improvement at 1B strictly for measuring defense. Cleveland is not afraid to make moves and added some pitching in an attempt to improve the 2025 roster. You are correct in positing that we shall see. I'm curious to see the Guards next move.
  17. tony&rodney
    Yes. The Twins have some talent. I don't dispute or overlook that there are good players on the roster. I saw the Twins in the beginning of the year too and was also cognizant that they feasted on the hapless White Sox. Their record versus winning teams left room for improvement. The pitching is good in my opinion. The team lacks speed and the gloves are poor as a team. Thus, I'm of the thought that to compete above a .500 level the Twins need to make a few changes. Specifically, the team needs to address the defense at two or more positions. I'm aware that many people on Twins Daily have focused on the big middle part of last season as more representative of the team looking to 2025. I wish that were true and I actually hope it happens. I just don't see it. It very well may be that the Twins believe totally in the current roster, leaving minor peripheral changes to the roster. I'm also not at all impressed by the limited payroll escape excuse. The Twins have the largest payroll in the AL Central and also have a much bigger payroll than the Brewers. The Guardians made a trade of their 31 home run hitting first baseman among other moves. MLB is a brutally cut-throat business. Teams have options and opportunities all around them. It is up to management to build the best roster. Again, I understand that there is a stance that strongly believes the current guys are the way forward. Hope it works.
  18. tony&rodney
    I saw a comparison of Luke Keaschall to Mike Trout. Please don't shoot the messenger. Also don't ever expect a Mike Trout out of Keaschall. Baseball loves to compare teenagers to superstars. Thankfully all mentions of Emmanuel Rodriguez being Juan Soto were flushed a couple of years ago. We can watch Cabo this coming year via milb.com and gain a clue how he is progressing.
  19. tony&rodney
    Cleveland is still around $45M below Minnesota in payroll, so they figured Santana works as a DH/PH/1B. Kyle Manzardo will get a ton of the time at first base. The Guards still are looking to add an outfielder and could have another $12M to spend. That team is resourceful and always looks both short term and long term.
  20. tony&rodney
    Agreed. There are also a dozen clubs that would love to have the financial resources of the Twins, including Milwaukee and the entire AL Central division. Everyone is doing the same thing except for a few teams.
  21. tony&rodney
    The physical that doomed the trade with the Cubs was after much of the speculation on Twins Daily. The Twins would have had to back out of any deal as well ..... or reduce their offer to the level of Philadelphia.
  22. tony&rodney
    Exactly why the Phillies have no problem trading him. Philadelphia does not roster players like you describe, no bat/ good glove other than as a backup catcher. Think Noah Miller. Thus, the trade makes sense even though Philly was not looking for a pitcher. Miami made them a deal they couldn't refuse.
  23. tony&rodney
    We do not know what the physical showed. Philly does. They have loads of young players and are a team trying to win now, so they gamble a prospect highly rated but from ROK/A ball. It makes sense. Remember, as much as Caba is loved for his glove, he is iffy with the bat. Jose Salas isn't way off if viewed from his status several years ago. Miami likely called on a ton of teams. You have to admit, given Luzardo's 2023 performance, that this looks like a panic trade. Miami doesn't want to gamble the $6M. Philly does. It can be safely stated that Miami has had some problems and maybe some bad luck too. In any event what a change from the recent post suggesting a trade for Jesus Luzardo. Without any knowledge of the medical issues, we cannot discern whether we (TD members) might have made a similar gamble with $6M and two ROK/A ball prospects.
  24. tony&rodney
    That is the comparison. They are so far away that evaluation needs to wait. There is evaluation before signing, development, and then more evaluation once they get to A+ or higher. Naturally, the coaches are always working with these young players on a entire raft of skills. Few 18, 19, or 20 year olds light up the world in baseball.
  25. tony&rodney
    Thank you for your money.
×
×
  • Create New...