I think these are two different cases to consider. Correa has been generally solid from a health standpoint throughout his career, with the exception being 2019 when he spent a chunk of time on the DL due to a non-baseball injury, and he's got an insane amount of playoff experience. Buxton, on the other hand, has never really been healthy compared to Correa, and has a total of 3 games of playoff experience. I guess what I'm saying is Correa has a playoff track record, Buxton does not. I'd love to see a healthy Buxton playing for us, and playing up to his potential, but this year isn't going to be the year for that.