Two Aces and a King: The Trio That Made Minnesota Believe in 2006

[Cody Christie]

Image courtesy of © Jason Bridge-Imagn Images

It's hard to believe two decades have passed since the 2006 Minnesota Twins season. For much of that summer, the Twins looked like a legitimate World Series contender, fueled by a trio of stars who seemed nearly impossible to stop.

Joe Mauer was emerging as baseball's premier catcher. Johan Santana was solidifying his place as the best pitcher in the game. And a rookie named Francisco Liriano arrived with a level of dominance rarely seen from a first-year player.

Looking back 20 years later, it's hard not to wonder what might have happened had all three remained healthy and at their peak when October arrived.

The King: Joe Mauer

2006 First Half: .378/.446/.535 (.981), 7 HR, 1 3B, 22 2B, 38 BB, 30 K

Mauer's rookie season in 2004 was interrupted by a torn medial meniscus, and although he played 131 games in 2005, he was still developing into the superstar many envisioned when Minnesota selected him first overall in the 2001 MLB Draft. His 107 OPS+ showed promise, but 2006 became the season where everything clicked.

The first half was a masterclass in contact hitting. Mauer entered the All-Star break leading the American League in batting average.  By season's end, Mauer became the first catcher in American League history to win a batting title, finishing at .347. He earned his first All-Star selection, captured his first Silver Slugger Award, and announced himself as one of baseball's elite players.

For Twins fans, that first half served as the opening chapter of a Hall of Fame career.

 

Ace No. 1: Johan Santana

2006 First Half: 19 G, 131 IP, 2.95 ERA, 138 K, 1.00 WHIP, .629 Opponent OPS

Santana entered 2006 with something left to prove. He had already won the 2004 Cy Young Award, and many believed he was deserving of the honor again in 2005. Instead, he finished third despite leading the American League in strikeouts, ERA, WHIP, and several advanced metrics.

Whether fueled by that perceived snub or motivated by the electric young left-hander sharing his rotation, Santana delivered another dominant first half. Every fifth day, he overwhelmed hitters with a devastating changeup that remains one of the best pitches of the modern era. His 138 strikeouts before the break led the American League, and he continued to establish himself as the standard for pitching excellence.

The second half only strengthened his Cy Young case. Santana finished the season leading all of baseball in wins (19), ERA (2.77), strikeouts (245), WHIP (0.99), ERA+ (162), and rWAR (7.6). He was the unanimous AL Cy Young Award winner, receiving all 28 first-place votes. Yet, for a brief stretch during the summer, there was a legitimate debate about whether he was even the most dominant pitcher on his own team.

Ace No. 2: Francisco Liriano

2006 First Half: 22 G, 88 1/3 IP, 1.83 ERA, 102 K, 0.97 WHIP, .543 Opponent OPS

Few pitching prospects in Twins history have generated as much excitement as Francisco Liriano. The left-hander opened the season in a multi-inning relief role, giving Minnesota a weapon unlike anything else in baseball. Over his first 22 1/3 innings, he struck out 32 batters while walking only four and posted a 3.22 ERA.

The Twins moved him into the starting rotation on May 19, and his season immediately took off. Over his next 10 appearances before the All-Star break, Liriano allowed just 10 earned runs while striking out 70 batters. He posted a remarkable 1.36 ERA as a starter, and Minnesota went 9-1 in those games. His slider was unhittable. His fastball exploded through the zone. Hitters often looked defeated before stepping into the batter's box.

Initially left off the American League All-Star roster, Liriano eventually earned a spot after injury replacements opened a place on the team. He joined Mauer and Santana in Pittsburgh, giving Minnesota three of the game's brightest stars on baseball's midsummer stage.

At that point, it appeared the Twins had assembled the type of top-of-the-rotation duo capable of carrying a club deep into October.

 

The Second-Half Fallout

Unfortunately, the story took a heartbreaking turn. Liriano was scratched from a late-July start because of forearm inflammation. Initial examinations revealed no structural damage, creating optimism that the issue would be minor. That optimism disappeared on August 7 when he left a start after throwing only 67 pitches because of renewed elbow discomfort.

After rest and a brief rehab assignment, Liriano attempted a September return. It lasted just 27 pitches. During that outing, he felt and heard a "pop" in his elbow. The diagnosis ultimately led to Tommy John surgery in November, ending his season and forcing him to miss all of 2007. The injury robbed Minnesota of one of baseball's most electric young pitchers and permanently altered the trajectory of what looked like a budding superstar career.

A Team Built to Dream

The Twins still won 96 games and captured the American League Central despite beginning the season 25-33. They surged during the second half behind Mauer's batting title, Santana's Cy Young season, and a roster that found its identity after a sluggish start.

However, the loss of Liriano cast a shadow over everything that followed. Minnesota entered the postseason with legitimate championship aspirations, but the pitching staff no longer featured the devastating one-two punch that had terrorized opponents during the summer. The Twins were swept by Oakland in the Division Series, extending a frustrating postseason trend that had haunted the franchise since 2002.

Twenty years later, the memories remain vivid. Mauer became a Hall of Famer. Santana cemented his place among the greatest pitchers of his generation. Liriano's brilliance still sparks conversations about what could have been.

Together, they formed a trio that made Twins fans believe a World Series was within reach. That's why the 2006 season remains one of the most fascinating "what if" chapters in franchise history—a summer when Minnesota had two aces, a king, and every reason to dream.

What stands out about the 2006 season? Leave a comment and start the discussion.

 

View full article

[Linus]

Fun. I love a good change up so watching Johan was a joy. His mechanics were so clean I thought he wouldn’t get hurt but he eventually did. I also enjoyed seeing a certain reporter assigned to cover Johan in those days. Liriano was a completely different style of pitcher with a violent delivery that was doomed to cause injury. His slider was almost unhittable. And Joe, it’s hard to imagine right now having a catcher that good on both sides of the ball. I believe he had a season where he threw out 40% of attempted base stealers and had a 400 OBP.