Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • entries
    894
  • comments
    3,748
  • views
    1,629,922

Keep Your Unwritten Rules, Let the Kids Play


Twins Video

Last night Fernando Tatis Jr. got a grooved fastball in a 3-0 count and sent it into orbit. The San Diego Padres were already up seven late in the game, and with the bases loaded, his grand slam put it way out of reach. Texas Rangers manager Chris Woodward, he of the crotchety old age of 44, took exception to it.

 

Woodward told reporters after the game, "I didn't like it personally. You're up by 7 in the 8th inning, it's typically not a good time 3-0. It's kind of the way we were all raised in the game. But ... the norms are being challenged." He literally was asking for his opponent to quit playing. After Major League Baseball marketed their young talent wonderfully during the 2019 season with the slogan “Let the kids play” this is where we’re at.

 

I have no problem with baseball having unwritten rules. I think there’s a certain level of affection I have reserved specifically for the nuances in the sport. By and large though, the vast majority of said unwritten rules are dated and should be re-evaluated. Retaliation in the form of beanballs has long been silly. Bunting late in a game solely to break up a no-hit bid is one I think should draw some ire. If a pitcher wants to get on you for walking unnecessarily over his mound, so be it. Suggesting there’s counts in which the pitcher should know what the batter is doing though, and even further, completely expecting them to give up, is not a good look.

 

More often than not a 3-0 count results in a take due to the game scenario. Unless the pitch is absolutely grooved, that’s not a situation in which you want to miss and make an out. If a pitcher is going to throw a get-me-over fastball though, by all means the batter should be locked in and ready to ride it into orbit.

 

When Fernando Tatis Jr. did just that, his own manager Jayce Tingler missed the mark in defending him. Instead of noting that there was a sign missed, he simply could’ve said that he put a great swing on the pitch. Sure, missing signs is suboptimal, but that’s not the talking point in that specific spot. It’s like the basketball coach wanting the guard to work the offense, but he steps back and drains a three, which then causes exhale anyways.

 

 

There were takes all over the place in the wake of Tatis’ performance. Many of them correctly called out Woodward as off base and old school. Former Twins pitcher Phil Hughes chimed in comparing the situation to that of a football team taking a knee. The difference between all of those types of comparisons however is that baseball is the lone sport not dictated by time. When you’re up against a clock, strategy involved suggests killing the seconds and minutes in order to get you closer to victory. Baseball has outs, 27 of them, all finite. The only strategy when it comes to results in baseball is scoring more than the opposition before your self-inflicted missed opportunities run out.

 

 

If you want to be mad at a guy for swinging 3-0 at a bad pitch and giving up an opportunity to get on base, so be it. If you want to get mad at a guy for putting the ball in the seats, under any circumstances, by all means hop aboard the leather and ride it right on outta here.

 

For more from Off The Baggy, click here. Follow @tlschwerz

10 Comments


Recommended Comments

Dantes929

Posted

"Bunting late in a game solely to break up a no-hit bid is one I think should draw some ire."   I might agree with this if your team is up by 15 with 2 outs in the 9th...Maybe.   Otherwise, absolutely not.   Why should a team care about the opposing pitcher's no hitter aside from trying not to be the team he no hits?   What value is a no hitter if the opposing team doesn't use every way at their disposal to get a hit?  I've been a fan of baseball for 50 years.   I didn't grow up with this kind of BS.

Ted Schwerzler

Posted

 

"Bunting late in a game solely to break up a no-hit bid is one I think should draw some ire."   I might agree with this if your team is up by 15 with 2 outs in the 9th...Maybe.   Otherwise, absolutely not.   Why should a team care about the opposing pitcher's no hitter aside from trying not to be the team he no hits?   What value is a no hitter if the opposing team doesn't use every way at their disposal to get a hit?  I've been a fan of baseball for 50 years.   I didn't grow up with this kind of BS.

I'm not hard and fast on that one, but I do think it's kind of crappy to say we've been dominated for 7 or 8 innings, I'm going to try and bunt since I can't hit. It sounds dumb typing that out though, so maybe more strictly against the shift.

 

Or well, just #NeverBunt 

Channing1964

Posted

How you gonna expect a young dude like Tatis jr. to throttle it back? Man hes gonna mash it all he can. If you don't like it then don't fall behind by umpteen runs and expect everybody to give you a chance to toss your damn #15 reliever in there. I've seen the Rangers AND the Royals a lot in spring training(they share the complex in Surprise, Az) and there are no two bigger whining teams in the MLB. Maybe it's time Nolan Ryan calls Woodward into his office and tells him to STFU.

Ebby Calvin Laloosh

Posted

Do teams only look at stats put up in close games to decide contracts? I'm pretty sure Tatis gets paid to hit dingers. The more he hits the more he gets paid. To channel Sprewell, Tatis has got a family to feed. Just because Texas is so bad he has to lose money on his next contract? Makes no sense...

h2oface

Posted

Good for Tatis. Sometimes baseball players are real babies. It is a game, after all.

 

A good bunt IS a hit. It is a great hit. It is a smart hit. No mater when or in any circumstance. 

mikelink45

Posted

 

I'm not hard and fast on that one, but I do think it's kind of crappy to say we've been dominated for 7 or 8 innings, I'm going to try and bunt since I can't hit. It sounds dumb typing that out though, so maybe more strictly against the shift.

 

Or well, just #NeverBunt 

I love it - why do you want your team to be no-hit.  Bunting is part of the game as we have already seen with the Twins this year.  If they can't field it, that is on the other team.

mikelink45

Posted

Can someone please write down all these imaginary rules so we can stop saying unwritten rules and expose them to the sunlight where they might whither like the vampires they are as they suck the life out of the games. 

jkcarew

Posted

Missing the point. He had the take sign. The entire issue is that he had the take sign. He didn’t “miss” the take sign...he ignored it. His manager was bailing him out by saying that he missed it. Sounds much better than going public with the fact that the rookie ignored the sign and just did what he felt like doing instead.

 

Should the opposing manager be whining about it? Not in my opinion. 7 run lead...but Texas did have two at-bats remaining. But, it’s not cool IMO, either.

Channing1964

Posted

*the rules change with the generations....Im sure Babe Ruth got thrown at...now if you hit somebody OMG. If you hit Ty Cobb you knew your 2b or Ss was gonna pay somehow. Thats why they say let the game police itself. Now everything is on youtube

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...