Agreed That's interesting, but is it a good or bad thing for the AL? The NL has a bunch of guys bunting because they really have little hope of doing anything else. I can appreciate small-ball if it's a well-reasoned strategy executed by a skilled batter. I appreciate it less when it's the last refuge of someone who really ought to be doing something else. I prefer the AL style, but I actually think MLB stumbled into a pretty good solution by having different rules in the two leagues. Now we have a comparison, we have something to discuss and argue about I don't see it. It's harder to hide an offensive black hole in an NL lineup when you already have one built in at the 9th spot. I'm not sure what you see now with Simmons, but I see a guy who is universally recognized as an outstanding major league player. I don't see how playing in the AL would have changed that. (Plus he played his college ball within walking distance of my house, so I would probably say good things about him anyway.) Molina had hit in the minors and was 22 in his first season. Florimon had not and was 26. Still, I don't remember Florimon being lambasted during the offseason. Plenty of people were skeptical of his ability to maintain even the poor offensive numbers he had, and a number of us preferred Escobar's upside because he's 2 years younger and was likely to take another step forward. There was plenty of discussion over where the line was offensively for Florimon's superior defense to offset it. There probably should have been for Molina, too, especially after his second full year, which was pretty putrid (53 OPS+). But still, Molina was only 23 at the time, plus he had some MLB bloodlines and the minor league track record. Florimon wasn't "run out of town" until he put up a -12 OPS+ in 86 PA. I'm sure a lot of that wasn't his fault - having his appendix removed during spring training set him back and he never really recovered. I think he still could have a role with a major league team, but I doubt he gets another chance to be the full time SS for a team. I can't see how playing for an NL team would have changed anything I'm not sure what alternatives StL had in 2005/2006, but the Twins had one in 2014 and he played pretty well. I believe the difference in runs between the two leagues is almost entirely due to the fact that every 9th batter is a pitcher in the NL. The AL teams also have the flexibility to match up a bit more late in games because they don't have to use PH for the pitchers all the time. I don't see an increased quality of defense and the small ball is almost exclusively the product of pitchers being forced to go to the plate and attempt to hit. There we agree again, although I think if we were forced to choose one style of the other, we would choose the opposite.