FTR, I preferred Maeda to other options coming out of ST. I almost always prefer a proven veteran to unproven youth.
What I absolutely positively do not agree with, is that somehow Meada gets the rotation spot, or keeps it, based on contract incentives.
Overcome by events, as I'd be shocked if Maeda doesn't go on the IL, but Maeda's results to date pretty clearly give cause for concern. Skipping a start, velo down, command spotty.