The problem with Gibson is defined in context. They may have to keep him. Bodies and money become the limiting factors. Next year's rotation you have Santana and Berrios. Gonsalves and Jorge are unlikely to be ready for the start of next year given their starts in AAA this year. That is not to say that one of them might not be ready by midseason next year. I think it would be reasonable for them to be considered your back up plan for mid season injury. Dillon Gee starting could be the team's viewpoint on the future of Hurlbut and Slegers. I think those four with Romero and the token veteran reclaim project are your Rochester starters and backup plan. The problem becomes slots 3-5 on the major league team. For better or worse Mejia sticks as the third holdover. Trevor May and Phil Hughes are coming off injury. It would not be prudent to count on them for the start of next year as starters. The team will need a free agent signing. Hopefully an overpay for one of the quality arms and not a Santiago type. It would be unlikely they can sign two given supply and demand. It may be hard enough to even sign one. There is not a large supply. There will be demand. That leaves the 5 spot. Enns has not shown much. Low priced one year contract veterans last year were Derek Holland, Tyson Ross, Bret Anderson, Jeff Locke, Scott Feldman, and Jered Weaver. What might be out there on a similar level this year is likely to perform about the same. Gibson is the devil you know. A low enough contract to dispose of if the minor league players develop. The front office looks less bad keeping him than signing a bad mediocre player. The average increase was 100% in arbitration. Earlier I pointed out the winners. Somebody does not get the big raise. One of those will be Gibson. He got his step up last year, when players get the payday in the first year of eligibility. Not this year. See Shelby Miller. See Caleb Joseph.