Cuddyer netted the team the draft picks that became JO Berrios and Chargois. The trade would have had to been made by Smith, not Ryan Morneau should have been traded in the Bill Smith era, between the 2012, and the 2013 Morneau there would be little difference in value. Wilingham never had value except in fan fantasies, Kubel was a liability in the field. If there was a market for him after his breakout season it was again a Bill Smith era thing to do. By the time Ryan took over again, Kubel was well known and down to a slightly above replacement level player. . Yup Arizona gave him a fat contract. At that time fat contracts were easier for teams to give for a player than a prospect. The prospect turned out to be Luke Bard as the compensation pick. That pick has not worked out, but a reasonably good choice. Edwin Diaz would have been better, but every GM passed on him a time or two when they should not have. Epstien got lucky. Right time, right place. Got a better deal than Boston did for worse pitchers. He still has the same job, Cherrington does not. Epstien dealing mediocrity having a great season for great prospects was about the last time it happened.