tony&rodney
Old-Timey Member-
Posts
10,785 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
94
Content Type
Profiles
Minnesota Twins News, Rumors & Analysis
Minnesota Twins Videos
2026 Minnesota Twins Top Prospect Rankings
2022 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Minnesota Twins Trade & Free Agent Rumors
Minnesota Twins Fan Guides & Resources
2023 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2024 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2025 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2026 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Forums
Blogs
Events
Store
Downloads
Gallery
Everything posted by tony&rodney
-
Cardinals (Leahy) vs Twins (Ryan): 6/12/26, 7:10pm
tony&rodney replied to Brandon Glick's topic in Archived Game Threads
I think the Twins wanted Kaelen Culpepper to play 75-80 games at AAA but it looks like he is ready. The defense is solid, he is a good base runner, and the patience has improved month to month. The bat has pop, both gap and over the fence. -
Cardinals (Leahy) vs Twins (Ryan): 6/12/26, 7:10pm
tony&rodney replied to Brandon Glick's topic in Archived Game Threads
Might be two weeks or so. KC made a phenomenal slide to beat the tag at home. He scored from second base on a ball that went off the first baseman's glove and only rolled to the edge of the infield grass. The young man is savvy. Atta fella Buck. -
Cardinals (Leahy) vs Twins (Ryan): 6/12/26, 7:10pm
tony&rodney replied to Brandon Glick's topic in Archived Game Threads
James Outman hits a home run in his first appearance with Detroit. -
I have not been upset with the catching very often. The middle infield specifically and corner outfielders most of the time are a problem. Glad I don't have to pitch with those guys behind me.
- 29 replies
-
- defensive runs saved
- fielding bible
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
I'm old. Haven't coached or scouted for a decade and haven't played for two decades. Still the eye test has a minimal piece of value, although I'm always willing to be taught/corrected and shown evidence that my old eyes are too weak. The defense needs help. It cannot roll in all at once and we fans must be at least a wee bit patient. Where are the weaknesses? P, C, 2B, SS, LF, and RF. CF and 3B are not that good. We should acknowledge that moving Brooks Lee to third base was a fair move and I do think he is about average and may improve. When Kody Clemens plays first base it is helpful for the pitchers. Trevor Larnach is massively improved from previous seasons but still not an outfielder unless he mashes on a consistent basis. Austin Martin has been ok but the bat has worms lately. Buxton is decent but not anywhere near his former self in centerfield. The mental errors have been reduced this season which is a start. I believe the players are working hard. A few are just short on talent. In time, with some good health and luck, Twins fans could see some new faces who will have a chance to raise the bar on batted balls. Hopefully this occurs by July and August to begin the transition to a better team.
- 29 replies
-
- defensive runs saved
- fielding bible
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
I do think athletes want a favorable pay timeline. Top baseball players make bank, both the top free agents and the top draft choices. I'm not too sure if many multi sport athletes could make it in baseball though. The skills are so different and the greatest difference is the amount of failure encountered in baseball. The percentage of baseball players who run into tough times for lengthy resets is very high. Thus, I'm not sure baseball loses athletes to other sports. Another huge difference is size. Lineman and basketball players face daunting challenges when playing baseball. I saw Michael Jordan play minor league baseball and he wasn't good at all. He was an athlete but had very little idea in the field or at the plate. MLB and the PA need to work things out in private and come to some agreement before December. I expect an agreement. A lockout would be a real setback for baseball. There are many alternative sources of entertainment for people.
-
Andrew Morris is a work in progress with his breaking balls. He could really use a good changeup. He was working on his pitches at St. Paul to the detriment of his line score, not much different than veteran pitchers working on stuff in Spring Training. The biggest problem for Morris is the defense behind him. We don't even need to look at FIP if we have watched the games. When a pitcher needs to strike everyone out because the defense is deficient, there is bound to be some improved contact when the pitcher goes for the K. Put some defenders behind Morris and everyone will wonder how he improved so dramatically. His last outing was nearly a blueprint of how things have gone for Morris. He could use refinement at AAA but he has the stuff. The broken bats and weak contact are real. Most of the hard contact comes after the 3rd or 4th out, which is partly youth and partly extended pitches in an inning. I'm not down on Morris. There are not any pitchers in MLB that would put up fantastic numbers with the Twins current defensive alignment. I do think that some steps have been made that are making a difference. When Clemens plays 1B, Lee at 3B, and Martin in RF more plays are made in the field. Lewis might pick up 1B quickly. Second base, shortstop, left field, and catcher are lean. Buxton is not the centerfielder he once was due to injuries. It is what it is but change needs to happen before Twins fans can expect their team to move to .500 baseball or higher.
-
The Twins return from New York after the 4th of July weekend. One wonders if the decision is made at that point to go with a couple of AAA players, which results in the release of two of Arcia, Gray, Kreidler.
- 44 replies
-
- ryan kreidler
- tristan gray
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
This is exactly how the Twins and all fans should feel ..... because it ignores issues beyond any predictions, like service time and financial stuff, in favor of fielding the best talent and letting that talent learn and develop.
- 33 replies
-
- kaelen culpepper
- brooks lee
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
Wow. Maybe the only question about Witt Jr. when he was drafted concerned his hit tool. We cannot expect anyone to reach Bobby Baseball's skill level in the next few years. He is the fastest runner, has a rocket arm, is the best defensive player in MLB, and hits for 300+ total bases a year. There are things to like about prospects but Witt Jr. is a dream.
-
The White Sox and Rays are using a ton of young player. The Mariners mix in rookies as well. Hopefully, the Twins feel Culpepper is ready by the time June ends. Players on the 40 person roster cannot play in the minor leagues during a lockout. There isn't any reason to hold players back if they are ready to contribute at the MLB level.
- 33 replies
-
- kaelen culpepper
- brooks lee
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
I have long wondered if Royce Lewis might have had or now has more value as a trade piece. Brooks Lee looks far better at third base than Lewis ever did (someone can look up what the various stat sites say about that). I think Lee will also grow as a hitter and his ability to switch hit is an advantage. That takes away 3B from Lewis and he (and his agent) probably prefers the left side of the infield. What is not known at all to me is whether Lewis has any real value for other teams. Certainly there are teams looking for decent production from third base but there is no future in trading Royce Lewis if the return is only a risky lotto pick. So it seems like first base is a good spot for now and if a team (Boston, Milwaukee, ?) is interested they will need to pay with a strong prospect. Lewis is working hard to correct his flaws at the dish and he can be a key player for the Twins this year. I do wonder about his legs holding up and he seems likely to move on in a couple of years no matter what occurs. Lewis is under team control for two more years. Next year will not be very expensive. Where does Royce fit? A team might give up a really good prospect if Lewis shows consistently from now until late July. Ironically, Lewis may be most valuable to the future of the franchise in a transaction.
-
Twins 6, Tigers 4: Dingler? No, Dingers!
tony&rodney replied to Peter Labuza's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
The number of times that Twins pitchers have needed to get 4-5 outs in an inning due to substandard defense really makes it difficult for the manager because of pitch counts. Morris feels like he needs to strike every batter out because of the defense behind him, which is counterproductive to good pitching. It is going to take time but the Twins need to find players who can turn those outs into outs. Keaschall is a confounding player. His approach looks like he is trying to power the ball but he lacks any power. He has good speed but his jumps on ground balls look poor and he just has too many problems fielding ground balls. The lack of improvement is concerning, even if he is relatively inexperienced. Outfield seems like an option until one remembers that his arm is weak. I'm not sure what the Twins can do with Keaschall. The article that suggested he relax and play in AAA for a bit doesn't really fix his weaknesses either. We can be certain that conversations are ongoing among the dugout staff seeking solutions.- 12 replies
-
- royce lewis
- byron buxton
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
It seems strange that Royce has such an inconsistent base when he swings. The dancing feet issue (both moving) looks to be reduced, although it still exists. One can still see the backside buckle on many pitches that look like they may come inside and good sweepers/breaking pitches are really tough for Lewis. Most baseball players have a pretty consistent base when they swing. When Lewis has a solid base and firm backside he is a good hitter. The lack of production is a result of so much difficulty having a consistent process.
-
Wonder how Cholowsky compares to Brooks Lee? Lee had a better rated hit tool and was rated higher on speed coming out of college than Cholowsky now. Cholowsky has better ratings of power and defense than Lee did. Something tells me that the best pick for an infielder is extremely risky - Jacob Lombard. I find it impossible to second guess draft picks when I haven't seen them play. My only caveats are picking DH types or players with athleticism who have not shown much in terms of baseball ability. In other words, leave it to the scouts.
-
4 Under-the-Radar Twins Trade Candidates
tony&rodney replied to Cody Christie's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
Every player can be traded if the return makes sense. Who exactly are people targeting? Is it DSL, GCL, and FSL lotto tickets? I'm all ears for specific ideas. A month a go I floated a Wallner for a Comp Pick to Arizona. I don't know if that works. Talk to everyone, but trade only if the transaction makes sense.- 31 replies
-
- kody clemens
- yoendrys gomez
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
Wonder how it helps to conduct/ share negotiations publicly. Hopefully a decent CBA gets worked out soon. The history of MLB labor disputes is not pretty. The 1987 and 1991 Twins flags are even affected by the shenanigans that took place in past disputes. The collusion of that era was quite severe. Some of you will remember that some of the best players in the game received zero offers. Andre Dawson, Gary Gaetti, and Jack Morris were among the dozens of players who had to take what they could get. Dawson was the most illustrious example. MLB was found guilty in the ensuing lawsuit and paid billions in penalties. Unfortunately, the MLBPA and MLB still harbors ill will towards each other and the loser is always the fans. I cannot see much traction towards a solution in the current published positions. Once again, it seems like fans will take the brunt of raised ticket prices or it seems inevitable. I'll just hope for the best as neither position makes me feel comfortable that the parties have the future of the game in mind.
-
Week in Review: 'Better' vs. 'Good Enough'
tony&rodney replied to Cory Moen's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
Didn't call for the rookies now. In fact I have said Culpepper is more likely in July but late June would not be a surprise. The others are more August calls. The larger point is that there are players with a broader spectrum of skills that are coming and there is hope. The talent takes time and patience is required.- 20 replies
-
- joe ryan
- royce lewis
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
There doesn't need to be any concern about where Winokur plays defensively. If he can manage to rise through the system and reach MLB, it will be because he has learned to hit and produce offense on a consistent basis. The defense is already really good and would improve with repetitions, no matter the position. The speed, power, arm, and defense are above average. The hit tool is still a work in progress.
-
Week in Review: 'Better' vs. 'Good Enough'
tony&rodney replied to Cory Moen's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
Tune in and get a decent sample of the prospects.- 20 replies
-
- joe ryan
- royce lewis
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
The Twins Need to Cash in on Kody Clemens Right Now
tony&rodney replied to Sam Caulder's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
Every player can be traded if the return makes the roster/team better. I cannot see any trade that involves Kody Clemens returning a player of note. There is not likely to be any demand unless we are talking cash. -
Week in Review: 'Better' vs. 'Good Enough'
tony&rodney replied to Cory Moen's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
Not at all. You need to consider that change happens. We are going to die some day. Different players take the place of those who are currently in place. It happens and nobody and nothing can stop time. There are players who are better and those who are not. Kirby Puckett arrived as a surprise singles hitter who held down CF. Everyone can have their own opinion on the next guys but they are coming. You may think that the prospects like Culpepper, Jenkins, etc. are the same as Julien, Wallner, etc., which is your right on this site, but I will suggest the next crew fields better, runs better, and will hit better. Choose the negative, laugh, and down vote but that only brands one as stuck in a bad place of negative thought. Finally, those who have negative views of the minor league players, please tell me you have watched at least 25 games to form your opinion as opposed to looking at lame data.- 20 replies
-
- joe ryan
- royce lewis
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:

