Jhoan Duran One of American League's Biggest All-Star Snubs

[Cody Christie]

Image courtesy of © Matt Krohn-Imagn Images

The Minnesota Twins will only send one representative to the 2025 MLB All-Star Game, and while Byron Buxton is a worthy choice and will even be competing in the Home Run Derby, it’s clear that the roster should include another Twin. Jhoan Duran, Minnesota’s electric closer, was quietly one of the most glaring omissions from this year’s American League squad.

Yes, the All-Star selection process has changed. Each league now carries a limited number of relievers, making the path to an All-Star nod even more difficult. When you look at the names who made it (Josh Hader, Andrés Muñoz, and Aroldis Chapman), it’s hard to say any of them are undeserving. But if there’s one reliever who should be heading to Atlanta and isn’t, it’s Duran.

Dominant, Despite the Save Total
Duran hasn’t piled up the saves like some of his peers this year, with just 13, but that’s no reflection of how dominant he’s been on the mound. The 27-year-old right-hander owns a 1.56 ERA over 41 appearances this season. He’s yet to allow a home run, and his strikeout rate remains excellent (26.8%). He’s anchoring a Twins bullpen that’s kept the team afloat (more or less) during an up-and-down first half. Duran is the type of player who can thrive in a showcase like the All-Star Game, when players are facing the best hitters on the planet. 

His lack of saves isn’t a matter of performance, but rather a product of Minnesota’s inconsistency in close games. The Twins haven’t provided him with the same volume of save opportunities as teams like the Astros, Mariners, or Red Sox have furnished his counterparts, but when Duran gets the ball in the ninth, he’s almost automatic. For the season, he has two blown saves, and he has yet to allow more than one earned run in any appearance.

Duran has already accrued 2.1 rWAR, the second-highest total of his big-league career. He’s been successful this season on multiple levels. He is getting one of the best ground-ball percentages in baseball (70.2%). When batters aren’t smacking the ball into the ground, it's often because they're missing the ball entirely; he's inducing whiffs on 31% of opponents' swings. If hitters do manage to make contact, even in the air, they are barreling the ball less than 3% of the time. His xSLG, wOBA, xwOBA, and xwOBACON each rank in baseball’s top 4%. The numbers are elite for a pitcher who has seen a velocity drop over the last two seasons. 

A Legacy of Elite Relief Arms
If Duran had made the team, he’d be the latest in a proud tradition of Minnesota relievers representing the club in the Midsummer Classic. Glen Perkins made three straight appearances from 2013 to 2015. Taylor Rogers earned a spot in 2021 as a very late addition to the team. Duran could follow a similar path in 2025. “Everyday” Eddie Guardado was a two-time All-Star in the early 2000s, and Joe Nathan became a perennial All-Star during the team’s AL Central dominance in the 2000s. Duran fits right into that lineage, as a high-leverage monster with stuff that leaves hitters baffled and fans buzzing.

Unfortunately, this year’s All-Star format didn’t leave enough room to include him. As bullpen usage continues to evolve and relievers take on greater importance in the modern game, limiting each league to a small number of bullpen spots feels increasingly outdated. If any position group deserves expansion, it’s relief pitching.

More Snubs in the Twin Cities
Duran wasn’t the only deserving Twin left off the AL roster. Matthew Trueblood recently wrote about Joe Ryan's case for inclusion, and he’s right, because Ryan’s underlying numbers are as strong as ever, and he’s become a model of consistency in the rotation. Like Duran, Ryan might have been a victim of the team’s lukewarm standing in the playoff race, making it harder for voters (including his fellow players) to reward his performance.

Still, if the goal of the All-Star Game is to highlight the very best of the game at the halfway mark, Duran (and Ryan) belong. Whether it’s lighting up the radar gun or locking down a late-inning lead, there are few pitchers more imposing or more deserving. Here’s hoping the snub fuels a dominant second half, and maybe a late push for some postseason hardware instead.

---

Was Duran snubbed from the All-Star team? Leave a comment and start the discussion.

View full article

[DJL44]

I would leave all the relievers off the All-Star Game roster if I had a choice. None of them are in the top 30 for pitcher WAR.

[ziggy]

Not only did Duran get snubbed off of the ASG roster, I have read a few articles about  snubbed players and he did not get a mention there either.

If I was managing to win the game, I would want 3 starters and the rest dominant set up men and closers.

[Fire Dan Gladden]

18 hours ago, DJL44 said:

I would leave all the relievers off the All-Star Game roster if I had a choice. None of them are in the top 30 for pitcher WAR.

By that logic, there would be no punters, kickers, or special teams guys recognized by the NFL.

Relievers are a position that needs to be represented.

[DJL44]

3 minutes ago, Fire Dan Gladden said:

By that logic, there would be no punters, kickers, or special teams guys recognized by the NFL.

Relievers are a position that needs to be represented.

Relievers are a not a position just like "slot receiver", "nickel back" or "long snapper" are a not a position. The position on the field is pitcher, just like the positions for football are wide receiver, cornerback and center.

[jorgenswest]

We need a different word than snub. Snub means ignored, rebuffed or spurn disdainfully. Honestly now I need to look up rebuff and spurn to figure out if any fits.

He wasn’t ignored. He wasn’t rejected in an ungracious manner. There was no disdain. He didn’t make the team though he and others that didn’t make the team were comparable to some that made it.

The all star team starts with those votes in. Next the need to try to take the best player from teams not represented. That to me is clearly Byron Buxton. I don’t think Jhoan or Ryan were snubbed. That is a weighty word that makes it personal. The author ups the ante by claiming that it is not only a snub but the largest snub. Now it is really personal. Byron’s season has been better and got the honor to represent the Twins. The Twins have done nothing to earn more representation. 

 

[dex8425]

22 hours ago, DJL44 said:

I would leave all the relievers off the All-Star Game roster if I had a choice. None of them are in the top 30 for pitcher WAR.

I assume you are not in favor of Billy Wagner, Trevor Hoffman, Rollie Fingers or Goose Gossage being in the hall of fame either then. Good thing you don't have the choice. 

[DJL44]

4 hours ago, dex8425 said:

I assume you are not in favor of Billy Wagner, Trevor Hoffman, Rollie Fingers or Goose Gossage being in the hall of fame either then. Good thing you don't have the choice. 

I would vote no on all of them except Gossage. Billy Wagner as a Hall of Famer while Johan Santana can't get 5% of the vote is a sick joke. Santana was at least twice as valuable as Wagner. Maybe if Santana had pitched less effectively he could have stayed in the bullpen and made it to the Hall of Fame.

[dex8425]

12 hours ago, DJL44 said:

I would vote no on all of them except Gossage. Billy Wagner as a Hall of Famer while Johan Santana can't get 5% of the vote is a sick joke. Santana was at least twice as valuable as Wagner. Maybe if Santana had pitched less effectively he could have stayed in the bullpen and made it to the Hall of Fame.

Johan will definitely get in via one of the committees in the future. He debuted on a very crowded ballot, unfortunately.