Cannot even begin to express how much I HATE when this organization develops an ace starter once in a generation and then trades him away rather than find a way to keep him.
If SWR is not a LOT better than Blackburn it's a good thing there are a half dozen guys on the farm that probably are. Something that could NOT be said in 2010.
I don't think they do either. Just not sure it's wise not to. The difference between him and Buxton is that when Buxton does play defense he can do so at a world class level. Lewis, not so much.
And the amazing thing is that stuff like this NEVER happens to other clubs. Excuse me, Mr. Boone on line 1, Mr. Roberts on line 2, Mr. Hyde on line 3, Mr. Bochy on line 4, Mr. Cora on line 5, Mr. Schildt on line 6, Mr. Hinch on line 7.
And today we see once again the Lewis would most likely be best served playing a spot which requires the least amount of wear on a fragile body. Why trade one of your two starting-caliber for something else when that something else might well be someone to fill a spot that you could move one of them to. Actually I'm not totally against Lee being the guy who ends up at 1B but I think he presents more options in other positions that Lewis does. The position I'm most interested in seeing Lewis occupy is "Activated from Injured List."
The Yankees have a need so let's trade or best pitcher. How about we use the fact that we have three of the twenty best starting pitchers in the game to OUR advantage on the field. The drop off beyond the big three is massive. Why mess the best thing that you have going for you?
AK wasn't really an "investment" he was more of a "hope" who didn't make it anywhere else so we throw him in at 1B. If your "investment" retires with a career .1 WAR, you might want to reevaluate your portfolio. His biggest career achievement was that he team had enough confidence in him as a 1B that they felt they could trade a batting champion for the closest thing they've had to an ace in a generation.
IF they had any defensive chops they wouldn't have been moved to 1B in the first place. Moving them isn't going to magically make them Keith Hernandez.
Height is more of a "nice to have but not terribly essential" thing at 1B. I'd be more concerned with having a guy who can hit the cover off the ball and hopefully play a little defense as well. If he's tall that's cool.
That clear plan for the future SHOULD be Royce Lewis. Would LOVE to see the IF settle in on Lewis at 1B, Keaschall at 2B, Lee at 3B & Correa at SS for the next 2-4 years. There should be a fairly large bubble of guys knocking at the doorstep in about two years. Expect to hear a lot about names like Kaelen Culpepper, Kyle DeBarge, Danny DeAndrade & Santiago Leon.
How is espousing the talents, character and virtues of one player insulting others? Am I saying there hasn't been much heart on the team the last four years? Hell yes. The the results on the field speaks to that. Not sure why you care. Pretty sure you'll tell me heart doesn't matter as much as some ******** analytic anyway.