At this point we start falling into the “was he healthy” trap, depending who our favorite players are and what arguments we are making.
Was Rosario underperforming because he was battling injuries, or not? Was Correa underperforming because he was battling injuries, or not? What about Kepler? What about Larnach? With Larnach, it was actually an illness that knocked him out the first time last season. Is it really fair to your analysis to just say he’s no good, without taking into account as much information as possible?