Anywhere between Jorge Polanco (pretty bad in the field) and Carlos Correa (top 5 shortstop) would be fine with me, and probably most fans. And I was fine with Polanco (as a stop gap).
If this same Carlos Correa was on a different team, and that other team’s general manager called you up (let’s say you are the Twins GM) and offered you Correa and his remaining 4/125, what would you counter with?