I do think it’s a bit unfair to single out the Twins in regards to prospects that don’t develop as well as we hope. Yes, we want the Twins to improve, but they aren’t any worse than any other team in MLB in that regard. Take a look at top 5 prospects from each team from most years and you will find several that have struggled at the MLB level. I picked a few teams from 2020 and looked at their top 5 prospects:
Braves: Cristian Pace (#13 ranked MLB) is 27 and back AAA, Ian Anderson (27, back in AAA), Kyle Wright (30, back in AAA)
BAL: DL Hall has been up and down
BOS: 2 of top 5 are in AAA at 27 and 30 (Jeter Downs and Bobby Dalbec), Bryan Mata, Gilberto Jimenez
Cubs: Brailyn Marquez, Brennen Davis
A more recent example is Jordan Walker of the Cardinals. #4 MLB prospect in 2023. Hit .276/.342/.445, 16HR in 117 games in 2023. Walker hit .201 in 2024, and .215 in 2025.
I could go on, but every team has prospects every year that struggle or don’t develop as they expect. We just don’t hear about them very often and certainly don’t see it on a daily basis. Could/would we like the Twins to get better?…yes, but every team goes through this. The question remains, how much more rope do we give Julien/Gasper/Outman/etc…before placing them on waivers and moving on?