The key question might be: what kind of player is Dozier? He looked solid last year, and in the early going this year, he looks like a star (at least, outside his AVG). But it's probably too early to tell if he is or ever will be a star, given his track record. Span's deal would actually be pretty nice. 5 years, $16.5 mil, covering two pre-arb seasons and 3 arb seasons guaranteed, with a $9 mil team option for the first free agency season. Scale that up for the intervening 4 years of baseball inflation and it seems like it could be appropriate for Dozier right now. They even have somewhat comparable track records (decent pedigrees but not top prospects, some struggles in the minors and/or early MLB). The tricky part may be that, at that time, Span had almost 2 seasons under his belt at a 4+ WAR per season pace and 117 OPS+. (Turns out they were his 2 best seasons at the plate, unfortunately!) Thanks to his slow start in MLB, Dozier only has about 1 season at that level. By the time he finishes 2014, he could have a more comparable track record, but he will also be one year closer to arb and free agency, which should bump up his contract by comparison. (Also, obviously, he could finish 2014 pretty strong and get a bump too.)