You are largely ignoring and side-stepping Mike's point. The Twins did not get 20 WAR from any combination of 8 guys last year. They got 14 from their best 8. The problem with your entire post is that it's ridiculously unfair. You're not even attempting something approaching an objective, fair analysis. You assume the worst about the Padre situation with Machado and potential for injury and assume the best for the Twins. Statistically speaking, there is no merit to the idea the Twins are sitting on 20 WAR with any combination of players but for best case scenario. The issue with not having superstars is it requires many players to simultaneously have kick-ass seasons. Sure, that can happen. It's also unlikely. When you plug a consistent force into your lineup, it reduces the risk you face when other players struggle and increases your upside if those players succeed. There are reasons to be a skeptic about a deal like this, but you did not lay out a fair, and thus, a not at all convincing case.