It doesn't matter who you use, and Sickels was just the opinion de jour, with its own thread today. Pipeline is fine, too. Fangraph's.... whatever. Ben Noble's opinion is just as valid, in my opinion. Maciel was considered the prize of the trade by some. I thought "But we all have opinions....." coverered the multitude of opinions and included them. I have a hard time getting excited about mid level prospects, of which, probably, most will never make it out of the minors. Lots of those is still not much, unless you just like minor leauge ball, which is a lot of fun. To each its own.