I guess we'll have to agree to disagree. If Duffy would have pitched like he did late last summer, in my opinion, he'd be in the rotation. As far as the 'uninspiring' group of relievers, Tonkin is out of options, freeing up another spot gives them the chance to kick the can down the road 6 weeks, gives Tonkin a true chance to succeed - or get cut. It gives the next group of relievers, starting with Burdi, a chance to compete, to prove with their performance "pick me, pick me".