It's not called the best player award though and the voters for the award aren't asked who they'd pay the most for to start their team. I also absolutely do not agree that the best player and the most valuable player are the same thing, just as I wouldn't think the best movie (The Godfather) and the most important movie (Citizen Kane) have to be the same thing. I digress though because the debate wasn't really my point, it was simply that I'd like the absence of a debate because I recognize everyone views this differently. Make a high profile award for the best hitter, just like they do the best pitcher and then there's no conflict. The NHL and College Football do this, though I'd draw the line at one additional award, not 2-3 thousand like those sports.