I'm not sure what caused his down year and I agree that he still has potential, but I'm of the mind that most of his problems are self-inflicted. Perhaps he doubts his secondary pitches but he shouldn't and I'm not sure that's the case. I have a hard time thinking of Gibson without getting frustrated with this direct quote he gave to Fangraphs: “I have this debate with Glen quite a bit: How effective an out on two or three pitches is as opposed to a strikeout. For me, a soft ground ball is just as effective if it’s within the first two or three pitches. If I’m able to keep my hard contact rate low, ground balls are almost automatic outs for me. “When hitters puts balls in play, they’re going to get a hit sooner or later. But if I get five ground balls in a row, I’m more than likely going to get out of the inning. Offensive numbers will tell you that. If they only get a hit three out of every ten times they put the ball in play, that’s less than two out of five, so I like my chances.” http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/kyle-gibson-on-pitching-to-contact/ 1) He isn't getting outs on two or three pitches. 2) He's not getting soft contact on his sinker or four-seamer. 3) He isn't likely to get five groundballs in a row as evidenced by the fact that he only had a 54% GB rate on his sinker (!) last year. Meanwhile if softly hit groundballs are so important, his Changeup and Slider both had a nearly 48% GB rate, with his change actually getting more GB than his sinker in 2014 AND 2015. The offspeed pitches also had wiff rates of 32% and 43% while the sinker only got wiffs 7% of the time. http://www.brooksbaseball.net/outcome.php?player=502043&b_hand=-1&gFilt=&pFilt=FA|SI|FC|CU|SL|CS|KN|CH|FS|SB&time=year&minmax=ci&var=gb&s_type=2&startDate=03/30/2007&endDate=01/03/2017 4) Listen to Glen, he's been around longer and probably has some good insight into the value of the strikeout. Gibson is stubborn and/or is listening to the wrong people about how to use his pitches. If that's truly the problem that should be fixable with the right superior telling him he's got to change his approach. Gibson's best pitch is his changeup, I'm hopeful Falvey/Lavine/Allen tell him he's not a sinkerball pitcher, he's just a pitcher who has a sinker he can use from time to time.