Replacing Schafer with Bonifacio would be an significant improvement. Only one set of projections are out but Schafer projects to a 615 OPS. Schafer is a poor defender in CF and below average in LF. He doesn't play IF. It isn't enough improvement though. I want them to stick with Schafer so that it is easy to bring up Rosario if he starts well. If not Rosario, then Sano and move Plouffe to LF. If not Sano, then Buxton. If not Buxton, then give Hicks another long shot. The one projection out has him improving to a .668 OPS. It is too easy to sign below average players because the other opening day choice is even worse. The player signed, though, gets far too much playing time. I am all in if they want to sign a top quartile player at any position. Barring that, they need to avoid the below average and invest in the future.