I would say he would have been a qualifying offer candidate had he reached free agency this year, and he likely will be next year, even with a similar up and down season. He might take a qualifying offer next year as a pillow contract, effectively extending him through age 32 season. And then he walks, and we aren’t stuck with an aging pitcher. Or he takes the most guaranteed money available, and we get compensation.
So any offer we get would have to be better than a compensatory pick. You’d think he is worth more now than mid next season, since an acquiring team this winter would get to issue a QA next offseason.
Of course, this is all assuming the QA system is still in place next CBA. It looks like MLB has proposed elimination of it as a concession to players in their proposals for the next CBA.
I don’t really want to extend him. Those are the kind of contracts that limit roster construction on teams like the Twins. The Rays and Brewers would trade him, right?