I don't think anyone is saying it's a fluke - his production has been pretty consistent for several years over several levels. It's just that his type of production in the minors doesn't normally lead to major league success. I did find one comp who turned out to be pretty good (until he hurt his hip.) He didn't spend much time in the minors, more because of who he was than because of his development, but he struck out more than 33% of the time in his 236 minor league PAs, and continued to strike out a ton while he finally became an outstanding MLB player by learning on the job. I'm sure Bo Jackson was a better athlete than ABW, but by all reports Walker is very athletic. The Kingman comp (post 54) is interesting, but his K rate was lower than 25% in the minors, he went straight from college to AA (he was the top overall pick in the draft), he only stayed in the minors for 682 PAs, and he was in the majors to stay by August of his age 22 season. With this comp, ABW is Kingman lite, at best. There is a possibility Walker will have a successful MLB career, but those K rates should really put a damper on expectations. despite current production levels, the odds area against him.