Sure he was 'given a shot.' Not at catcher, of course. But at 2B, CF, (where he'd never played before), and at 3B, where he made that one error that time, so of course he's no good. And then, he didn't put himself in the game when somebody, anybody, should have been PH'ing for BWilson in crucial situations, or anything like that. If MoY is in the dugout, does anyone from AAA actually get a real "shot?"