+1 well written. there's also a good Cricket analogy at Deadspin in the comments: "Cricket had a similar thing happen. Its version of being on base is having some part of the batter’s body or bat grounded behind a line. With the introduction of replay, people were getting called out because, after having crossed the line, were temporarily in the air while in mid-stride, and being (technically) correctly called out. But it turns out the official rule makers for cricket are actually a fairly sensible bunch, so they changed the law to say that, once you’ve made that initial contact behind the line with your foot, you’re safe. The baseball version of that change would be harder to make, but surely someone could come up with a rule (or a comment on the rule) that allows things like this to go unpunished while still punishing the guy that overruns the base or steps off while the ball is still live."