Fantastic approach Walt. I laud your effort, but agree with spycake. We’re looking for data points suggesting logic, when the basis for decision making is unwritten. If the rules for the game are clearly documented, but the rules for this scenario are adhered to as code but not documented, we’re looking for logic where none exists. It’s illogical to add unwritten rules to a written rule book. It’s illogical to have a moral code that says verbally, I guess, “play the game the right way”, “sportsmanship is ultimate” and “if you take offense to the other team, you should throw at them”. Molitor is a Savvy guy; he’s not going come right out and say he ordered the Profar plunking. However I can recall referring to these types of “rules” by the players , especially Dozier, and Molitor during Molitors tenure way more than I can recall during Gardy or TK’s tenures. Maybe it’s recently bias, but man it feels like Molly preaches from the unwritten gospel more than other managers.