First of all, why did you assume I used raw OPS? I didn't actually list any numbers. For what it's worth, I was going by OPS+ actually, which is pretty close to wRC+. Helton's last two seasons (that 88 and 87) weren't part of his big contract . Actually, to your point that we can't re-negotiate anything with Mauer, the Rockies actually did re-work Helton's deal -- he agreed to cut the final year salary of his big contract in half, in exchange for a 2/10 extension. In any case, Helton was only below 117 OPS+ twice through his entire big contract, again non-consecutive and once apparently while injured. Mauer had his poor injury season already in 2011, another tough year overall in 2014 (although not as bad as this year), and now of course 2015. If 2015's numbers are repeated in 2016, he's going to be well beyond Helton's threshold of big-salary suckitude.