I would sign him, but let him know I was unleashing the hounds on him - Arcia, Buxton, Kepler, Hicks, Rosario, even Walker: these guys are hungry and want to play. "Mr. Hunter, we welcome back your person into the team, but beware, you might want steel reinforced underwear, because they'll be chomping at ya. Competition is never a bad thing. BTW, if you look at Jeter's 39-40 seasons, and Hunter's, Torii mops up the floor with the captain, or Ripken. The one guy off the top of my head who performed better at 40 was Ibanez. And Thome offensively - Torii still plays the field. He really is a phenomenon.